Your job advert is online, but you’re not getting any applications. Or perhaps you are getting applications, but not from the sort of people you’re looking for. The question then is whether you should rewrite the text yourself or outsource the task.
The short answer: having a job advertisement written is particularly worthwhile if your vacancy is difficult to fill, if you don’t know what matters to your target audience, and if the text forms part of a campaign that you measure and adjust. Do you have a role for which enough suitable candidates are applying? In that case, writing it yourself is often perfectly fine.
When is it more worthwhile to have a job advertisement written for you?
Outsourcing is not an end in itself. It is worthwhile when your own text demonstrably isn’t delivering enough and you lack the in-house expertise or time to improve it. This comparison will help you make your decision.
| Situation | Writing it yourself is the obvious choice | Having it written down is the obvious thing to do |
|---|---|---|
| Number of comments | You’ll get plenty of suitable applicants | Hardly anyone responds, or it’s mostly the wrong people |
| Knowledge of the target audience | You know from conversations and figures what candidates consider important | Your text is based on what you think candidates want |
| Job type | A role that you can fulfil frequently and with ease | A rare profile in engineering, manufacturing, logistics, sales or the maritime sector |
| Distribution | The text is on your website, and that’s enough | The text must work in adverts, on a landing page and in the follow-up |
| Time and measurement | You’ve got time to test and make adjustments | Nobody checks the figures or edits the text |
Do you recognise yourself mainly in the right-hand column? If so, the problem is rarely just down to the wording. More often than not, it’s a lack of understanding of who you’re trying to reach.
What are the tell-tale signs of an underperforming job advert?
You don’t recognise a text that isn’t convincing by the feeling that it’s “pretty good”. You recognise it by what candidates do – or, conversely, don’t do. Look out for these signs first before deciding whether to rewrite it or outsource it.
Not enough people are responding
This is the best-known problem. According to research by UWV It appears that 87% of employers experiencing recruitment difficulties cite a lack of responses to job vacancies as the reason. Labour shortages are a factor, but a job advertisement that fails to appeal to the target audience exacerbates the problem.
Lots of views, few applications
Have you noticed that people are opening your job advert but not applying? If so, the content may be the reason. You should also check the application process, eligibility criteria and any technical barriers. Indeed It describes the journey from viewing the advert to clicking through to applying, and argues that job vacancies attract more applications if the job description provides relevant candidates with enough information and convinces them to apply. A high drop-off rate between opening the advert and applying is therefore a reason to take a critical look at your text, alongside those other barriers.
The wrong people are responding
According to the same UWV survey, employers with hard-to-fill vacancies often state that applicants lack the right skills (64%), professional knowledge (59%) or work experience (55%). Not every mismatch is down to the job advertisement. However, if your job advertisement is vague about the work itself, you’re more likely to attract the wrong sort of applicants.
The text was written primarily for internal use
Is your job advert a modified version of the previous one, or based on HR’s job description? And did nobody from the target audience have a look at it? If so, there’s a good chance the text speaks your language rather than that of the candidate.
What does target audience data contribute that internal assumptions do not?
The difference between an internally produced text and one based on target audience data lies in the starting point. When writing internally, you base your text on what you consider valuable. When using data, you base your text on what the candidate indicates they consider important.
That difference is greater than it seems. Employers often think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group actually has different priorities. FosFor bases this advice on data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, target audience data, public labour market data and competitor analyses. This covers terms and conditions of employment and fringe benefits, as well as communication and the application process.
This advice is well known even outside recruitment agencies. The UK government’s recruitment team advises in a blog about advertising job vacancies to test your advert with your target audience before publication. If you’re recruiting developers, ask your own developers what they think and incorporate that feedback.
Would you like to know exactly how to incorporate those insights into your text? Then read on to find out how to target audience data used in your job advertisement. For technical and blue-collar roles, it also helps to first Drafting the EVP, so that the text is underpinned by a clear employer narrative.
Which part of the text remains your responsibility?
Having someone else write the content does not mean you are relinquishing control over it. A writer or agency can formulate, organise and tailor the content to the target audience. The facts about the role come from you.
- Job description: what someone does on a typical working day, using which machines, dealing with which customers or working with which teams.
- Strict requirements: which qualifications, certificates or experience are actually necessary, and what you can learn.
- Terms and conditions of employment: salary, working hours, travelling time and other arrangements that you can fulfil.
- The application process: who gets in touch, how quickly, and what steps follow.
- The final verdict: It’s up to you to decide which candidate to hire.
A good start is a thorough initial discussion with your line manager. This Questions for an initial interview with the hiring manager help you clarify the job requirements. In the section on the process, you’ll read about how to explains the application process in your job advertisement.
Don’t promise anything in the job advertisement that you won’t be able to deliver in practice. A well-written advertisement that doesn’t match what’s discussed in the initial interview will still cost you the candidate later on.
How does a job advertisement become part of a wider campaign?
Many employers simply post a job advert and then sit back and wait. According to UWV For 82% of the vacancies, employers post a job advertisement; for 46% of the vacancies, this is the only recruitment method used. For 28%, they engage an external organisation.
When it comes to hard-to-fill roles, a simple job description is often not enough. If you also want to reach candidates who aren’t actively looking, the message in your text must also work effectively in adverts, on your careers page and during initial contact.
That is where the real difference lies between having a text written and having a text used. In a campaign:
- First, use data to determine what appeals to your target audience;
- translate that message into text, adverts and landing pages;
- you can identify where candidates drop out, from viewing the listing to applying;
- adjust your copy and targeting based on those figures;
- Respond to comments promptly and shortlist them.
This is how FosFor works too: a strategy based on data and the TEAM framework, targeted campaigns and the initial shortlisting of candidates. During a weekly strategic meeting, you discuss campaigns, results and next steps. On average, clients only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month, as FosFor handles the pre-selection and guidance. You can read more about this in our data-driven approach.
Would you like to see for yourself which figures you need to follow? If so, this article on Measuring recruitment campaign figures.
Do it yourself or outsource it: your next step
Start by taking an honest look at your current job advert. How many people see it, how many open it, and how many apply? And are those applicants a good fit?
If the figures look good, feel free to write the job advert yourself and ask someone from your target audience to proofread it. Has your vacancy been open for months and are you unsure where things are going wrong? If so, a lack of alignment with your target audience could be one reason, alongside labour market shortages, terms and conditions, reach and the application process.
Are you unsure which direction to take with your job vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your hard-to-fill vacancy. Together, we’ll assess whether a new job advertisement will suffice, or whether you need to broaden your approach.