Recruitment of a replacement for a key member of staff – when does it start?

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Is your only marine electrician, experienced service engineer or process operator due to retire soon, or is that employee leaving for another reason? If so, the short answer is: start recruiting as soon as you know the departure date. Don’t wait until their last working day. Count backwards from that date and add up the recruitment time, your new candidate’s notice period, the handover period and a buffer. That total is your lead time.

In practice, the opposite often happens. The US Social Security Administration describes this situation very accurately in its training course on succession planning: organisations usually know well in advance that a post is due to become vacant, but only start taking the process of filling it seriously once the departure date has arrived. According to [...], succession planning allows you to this SSA training module recruit candidates even before they leave, develop their skills and prepare them for the role.

In this article, you’ll find out how to determine whether a role requires such an early start, how to plan for the lead time, and what to do if the replacement doesn’t arrive on time.

How can you tell if a role poses a critical knowledge risk?

Not every departure requires months of preparation. A role becomes a knowledge risk if work comes to a standstill or errors occur as soon as that one person leaves. These questions will help you assess this:

  • Is there anyone who can take over the work tomorrow? If the answer is no, find out what knowledge is held solely by the departing employee and what colleagues are already able to take on.
  • Is the knowledge documented? Check whether work instructions, fault history, customer agreements and machine settings have been documented, or whether they are simply stored in someone’s head.
  • How rare is this profile? Check whether the role is on the list of shortage occupations. In our article on shortage occupations in 2026 you can read about which technical roles are included.
  • How many employers are fishing in the same pond? For a welder, for example, a shipyard, an installation company and a machine factory in the same region could all be competitors. A labour market competition analysis Show who you’re competing against.
  • What is the cost of downtime? Think of postponed projects, colleagues’ overtime or work you have to leave undone. You can read about how to assess this in Calculate the weekly cost of a vacant post.

If you score highly on two or more of these points, treat the role as critical. This is a rule of thumb rather than a measured standard, but it gives you a concrete starting point for your discussion with your management.

How much lead time is realistic for a specialist who is in short supply?

There is no fixed number of weeks that applies to every role. The lead time depends on four stages that you carry out in sequence. Add them together and count back from your current employee’s departure date.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.
Block What determines the duration? Where did you get that information from?
Preparation Drawing up a job profile, defining the target group and determining terms and conditions of employment An initial meeting with the line manager and the departing employee
Recruitment and selection Shortages in the profile, supply, channels, speed of your process Personal experience with previous job vacancies, labour market data
Candidate’s notice period The candidate’s contract with their current employer Check this early on in the selection process
Overlap and transfer How much knowledge needs to be transferred and how complex the work is Your own assessment, together with the employee who is leaving
Buffer Risk of a candidate withdrawing or an offer being declined Your own risk tolerance

How long does the recruitment process itself take?

This varies greatly depending on the role and approach. At FosFor, vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average. This is an average, not a guarantee. When planning, you should also take into account your candidate’s specific notice period and the time you’ll need for the handover.

If you wait until someone has left, you run the risk of the vacancy remaining open for a long time. The UWV explains that employers, when hard-to-fill vacancies go the extra mile: they leave vacancies open for longer, use different channels, call on their networks, offer training or engage an intermediary. Ultimately, according to the UWV, companies manage to fill almost two-thirds of those vacancies (eventually). Conversely, this means that some remain unfilled.

A hypothetical example of back-calculation

Suppose: your most experienced technician is leaving on (date X). You estimate that the recruitment process will take a few weeks; the candidate has a notice period of (unknown until you ask); and you want an overlap of (your estimate) for the handover. Add those timeframes together, factor in a buffer in case a candidate drops out, and you’ll know the latest date by which the campaign needs to go live. Has that start date already passed? Then now is the time.

What role does knowledge transfer play during the recruitment process?

Knowledge transfer is one reason to start earlier. A replacement who only starts after the departing employee has left may have to figure things out for themselves, particularly if little has been documented and colleagues are unfamiliar with the work. By shadowing the departing employee in advance, the replacement can acquire practical knowledge directly from them.

The US Geological Survey (USGS) explicitly cites the capture of knowledge from staff who are due to leave as an objective of succession planning. In their FAQ on succession planning They give the example of experienced technicians who mentor junior colleagues and document their knowledge using a set of standard questions.

You don’t need to wait until the replacement has been appointed before handing over. Start the following during the recruitment process:

  1. A knowledge inventory. Ask the departing employee to list the tasks that only they carry out, the recurring faults and the contacts they maintain.
  2. Frequently asked questions about transfers. For example: what would you tell a new colleague during their first week? What went wrong in the past, and why?
  3. A colleague as a second source of knowledge. Get someone from the team to start looking over the new employee’s shoulder, so that knowledge isn’t solely reliant on the new recruit.
  4. An induction plan. Decide in advance what the replacement needs to learn during the handover period. Our article on a 90-day development plan for a new employee helps you get started.

The skills assessment has another advantage: it helps refine your job profile. You can see which skills are genuinely essential and which requirements you can dispense with or teach during the induction period.

What happens if a replacement isn’t sorted in time?

This creates a gap between the departure of the current employee and the start of their successor. The extent of this problem depends, amongst other things, on how well you have already documented your knowledge and what colleagues are able to take on. Here are a few options for bridging the gap:

  • Temporary arrangements with the departing employee. Some people are willing to remain available to answer questions after they retire. Discuss this early on and put it in writing.
  • Internal succession planning. Perhaps a colleague could be promoted, whilst you look for someone from outside the company to fill their former role. Read how to weigh up the options in promote from within or recruit externally.
  • Review your requirements. The UWV cites the training of job applicants who do not yet have all the necessary qualifications as one of the ways in which employers can still fill difficult vacancies. A candidate with a strong foundation and a willingness to learn may be a viable option if the induction period is long enough.
  • Broaden your search. According to the same UWV source, utilising other channels and your own network are standard steps.

Have you noticed that this sort of staff turnover is becoming more common in your organisation, for example due to an ageing workforce? If so, a one-off vacancy isn’t enough. In that case, you should build a candidate pool for recurring hard-to-fill vacancies, so that you don’t have to start from scratch the next time you set off.

Here’s how to take the first step

Take a look at your team today and answer three questions: who is leaving in the near future, which of those roles are critical, and when, based on your calculations, should the recruitment process have started? That overview is enough to draw up a concrete plan.

At FosFor, we combine recruitment, data and marketing. Using target audience data and labour market data, we identify what matters most to your specialist, set up targeted campaigns and handle the pre-selection process. On average, clients only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates each month. Find out how this works in our data-driven approach.

Is a key member of staff due to leave? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll work with you to draw up a realistic plan for your situation.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.