Is there a vacancy, and is there perhaps already someone in your team who could take on the role? If so, the question is whether to promote from within or recruit externally. The short answer: opt for internal promotion if an employee will master the core aspects of the role within the foreseeable future and their current role can be covered. Recruit externally if you do not have the necessary expertise in-house, if the work cannot wait for a training programme, or if promoting an existing employee creates a new vacancy that is more difficult to fill than the original one.
Whether to promote from within or recruit externally is therefore not a matter of principle. It is a balance between three factors: the expertise you already have, how quickly the role needs to be filled, and what each route actually costs you. Labour market data helps you determine whether recruiting externally is a realistic option in your situation.
What signs indicate internal growth?
Internal promotion is the obvious choice if the gap between what an employee can currently do and what the role requires is small enough. A technician who has been working on the on-call rota for years often benefits more from mentoring than from a full training programme to become a work planner.
Look out for these signs:
- The specialist knowledge is specific to your organisation. Think of your own machinery, processes, customers or working methods, which an external candidate would only become familiar with after several months.
- There is a candidate who has demonstrated an interest. Someone who says they want to develop is usually more motivated than someone you push into a role.
- The missing part can be learnt. A certificate, leadership skills or planning knowledge can often be acquired within a reasonable period of time.
- The role can be partially covered on a temporary basis. If colleagues can cover the workload for a few months, there will be time to train someone new.
- The current role is easier to fill than the vacancy. If you promote an experienced employee and recruit externally for an entry-level role, you are shifting your search to a target group that is often easier to reach.
Do you want to ensure that internal candidates settle into their new roles smoothly? A clear plan for the first few months helps. In our article on what to include in a 90-day development plan You can read about how to put that together.
When is external recruitment quicker or more realistic?
External recruitment is the better option if the required knowledge or experience is not already present within your team and cannot be acquired within the time available. A manufacturing company introducing a new technology will not benefit from an internal candidate who has never worked with it before, if the production line is due to be up and running in six weeks’ time.
‘External’ is also the obvious choice in these situations:
- There is no suitable or qualified internal candidate. Promoting someone simply because they happen to be there often results in a dissatisfied employee and a role that is only half-filled.
- The role requires a fresh perspective. Sometimes you want to deliberately seek external expertise, for example when adopting a new commercial approach or dealing with a different type of customer.
- A training programme takes longer than you can wait. Every week that a post remains unfilled costs money. You can find out how to work this out in Calculate the weekly cost of a vacant post.
- Further expansion would leave a key position vacant. If your best technician is the only one who can set up a particular machine, you’re merely shifting the problem rather than solving it.
Speed is not a given when it comes to external recruitment. How quickly the process goes depends on the target group, the role and how attractive your offer is. At FosFor, vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average, and clients typically interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. These are averages, not guarantees for your vacancy.
What role does labour market data play in this assessment?
Labour market data tells you whether recruiting externally is a realistic option before you invest time and money in it. If there are many vacancies for the same role in your region and few people are immediately available, promoting from within becomes a relatively more attractive option. If there is a larger pool of candidates, recruiting externally is a more viable option.
The overall situation is tight. The UWV measures the tightness of the labour market by dividing the estimated number of unfilled vacancies by the number of people who have been receiving unemployment benefit for less than six months. According to that UWV stress indicator In the first quarter of 2026, too, demand for staff exceeded the supply of jobseekers, although the tightness of the labour market eased slightly in many occupations.
A national overview doesn’t tell you much about your role. To find out more, you can look more closely. In the UWV Job Market dashboard You can select an occupation or labour market region and compare it with another region or with national figures. The figures are updated four times a year. Please note that, since December 2025, the UWV has been using a different supplier for job vacancy data, which has led to minor changes in the figures.
As well as looking at what’s on offer, take a look at the competition too. Who else is recruiting for the same role, and on what terms? You can read about how to go about this in Labour market competition analysis: how to stand out. If you’d like to get started with free resources yourself, the overview of labour market data that you can use without expensive tools.
How do you prevent the plant from growing through and creating a new hole?
Every internal promotion leaves a vacancy. So don’t just look at the current vacancy, but at the whole chain: who will eventually fill the role left by the employee who has moved on, and how difficult is it to find someone with that profile?
A practical approach:
- Identify the key positions. Which roles are difficult to replace, and where is knowledge concentrated in a single person?
- For each role, identify who is ready or will be ready shortly. This allows you to see in advance whether there is sufficient internal follow-up.
- Check the job market for the vacant position. Is it easier to fill that post externally than the original vacancy? If so, the internal promotion route often works well.
- Schedule a transfer. Let the employee who is moving on document their knowledge or train a colleague before they leave the company completely.
This is, in effect, succession planning on a small scale. The US government agency OPM describes a similar approach for public sector organisations: assess key positions, identify talent risks and evaluate how ready potential successors are. That context is different from that of a technical SME, but the principle is applicable: look ahead before a departure or promotion takes you by surprise.
Decision-making framework: internal or external at a glance
Compare the options against the three factors set out in the briefing for your own job vacancy: knowledge, speed and cost.
| Factor | Internal promotion is the obvious choice if… | External recruitment is the obvious choice if… |
|---|---|---|
| Knowledge | the role requires a great deal of organisation-specific knowledge and the missing parts can be learnt | the necessary knowledge or experience is not available within your team |
| Speed | you can temporarily take on the work whilst you’re being trained | the post must be fully filled in the short term |
| Costs | training and support outweigh recruitment costs and the vacancy can be filled easily | A lengthy training programme or a vacancy that is difficult to fill costs more than an external recruitment drive |
| Labour market | The data shows that the profile is very scarce externally | The data shows that there are accessible options available in your area |
Often, the answer is a combination of both: you promote someone from within and recruit externally to fill the vacancy. In that case, the main question is which of the two roles is easiest to fill externally.
Not sure which route is right for you?
Start with two questions: can an employee take on the core responsibilities of the role within the time you have available, and can the position they leave behind be filled? If the answer to either of these is ‘no’, you’ll end up having to recruit externally, and in that case, what your target group really values is what counts.
FosFor combines labour market analysis, target audience data and recruitment marketing to determine how realistic an external search is and how to go about it. Find out more our data-driven approach or book an introductory meeting to go through your job vacancy and the potential career progression path together.