Is the same vacancy for a technician, operator or account manager advertised year after year? If so, you’re probably starting from scratch every time. You write a job advert, launch a campaign and wait for responses. Building a candidate pool breaks that pattern. You remain visible to your target audience and stay in touch with people who have already shown an interest. When the role becomes vacant again, you approach the people you already know first. This doesn’t guarantee a quick fill, but it does give you a head start.
Why a pool can give you a head start over having to start all over again
A candidate pool is a group of people you have identified as promising prospects. You stay in touch with them, even when there are no vacancies at the moment. This includes previous applicants, candidates who just missed out on the role, and professionals who responded to a recruitment campaign but weren’t ready to make the move at the time.
The principle is simple. Recruitment software company Greenhouse describes it as follows: instead of creating a new role for every new position to build a candidate pipeline from scratch, you should first reach out to your existing pool or network. If you maintain that group on an ongoing basis, you can speed up the recruitment process.
The difference lies in the starting point. With a cold start, you first need to build a following, gain trust and spark interest. With a warm pool, you’ve already done some of that work before the vacancy is even advertised.
For which roles is a standing pool of candidates most beneficial?
A talent pool is particularly worthwhile for roles that come up regularly and are difficult to fill. Recruiting a director once every five years requires a different approach to hiring a new service engineer every quarter.
More comments often do not solve the problem. British research by the CIPD shows that many organisations received more job applications. At the same time, 58% of employers reported an increase in unsuitable candidates, compared with 33% who reported an increase in suitable candidates. Just over half of the organisations that were recruiting found it difficult to attract candidates. This was particularly true for senior and skilled roles. The survey focuses on the UK market and therefore does not necessarily apply to your situation. You should therefore assess, during your own recruitment rounds, how many responses truly match the role that keeps coming up.
A pool is particularly useful if:
- the post becomes vacant at least once a year, for example due to staff turnover, business growth or retirement;
- the pool of suitable professionals is small and you keep coming across the same people;
- Good candidates do not usually look for jobs actively and therefore do not respond to your vacancy of their own accord;
- In every recruitment round, you come across strong candidates who aren’t quite the right fit or aren’t yet ready to make the move.
| Situation | Is the pool worth it? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A recurring, scarce specialist role | Yes | A suitable, available candidate from the pool could shorten the next recruitment process. |
| A recurring role with a wide range of opportunities | Limited | A single campaign often generates enough suitable responses. |
| A one-off, highly specific role | Usually not | The maintenance costs are not worth it for a single use. |
In the blue-collar, sales and maritime sectors, this includes technicians, operators, logistics roles, commercial field sales roles and skilled tradespeople such as welders or ship’s electricians.
What role does an ongoing campaign play in filling your pool?
A talent pool doesn’t fill itself. An ongoing campaign can help you remain visible to your target audience and add new candidates to the talent pool, even between two vacancies. Particularly for skilled professionals who aren’t actively looking, this visibility can help you come to their attention before they’re ready to make a move. You can read about how to reach this group in the article on reaching passive jobseekers.
An ongoing recruitment campaign looks beyond a single vacancy. You don’t just count applications; you also count how many suitable candidates indicate that they’d like to be kept informed of future opportunities. This allows you to build up a pool of candidates without there necessarily being a vacancy at that moment.
Once candidates are in your pool, it’s time to keep them engaged. LinkedIn recommends that you to run personalised outreach campaigns for each target group segment. The idea is to keep people engaged with your organisation. If a suitable role then becomes available, a recruiter can approach them quickly, making the step towards applying for the job a little easier.
The message determines whether people stick around. Employers often think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target audience actually has different priorities. A campaign that addresses what a mechanic or sales assistant really values will attract a different audience to one full of generic employer promises.
How do you stay in touch with candidates who haven’t been hired?
The candidate who came second is often your best starting point for the next round. That only works if you wrap up the contact properly. Someone who hasn’t heard anything after three interviews is unlikely to reply to your message later on.
LinkedIn recommends that you to let candidates know when they are no longer under consideration and ask if you may contact them regarding future opportunities. Provide feedback if it will genuinely help the candidate. Also ask for feedback on your own process. Broken down into steps:
- Sign off personally. A phone call says more than a standard email, especially after several conversations.
- Ask for permission. Ask if you may contact the person again at a later date and make a note of the purpose for which you are retaining their details. Also read up on the rules regarding Retention of application data in accordance with the GDPR.
- Give constructive feedback. Stick to points that the candidate can relate to.
- Please note down why it didn’t go ahead. Was it the timing, the salary, the commute or the job content? You’ll find out later whether the situation has changed.
- Plan your next meeting. LinkedIn suggests, as a rule of thumb, about once every 30 days, depending on the needs of your target audience. Sometimes a quick check is enough.
If candidates drop out of your process at an earlier stage, you’ll miss out on them for your talent pool as well. So be sure to also check out the the main causes of drop-off in the candidate journey.
How can you prevent your pool from becoming outdated or unusable?
A list of names you haven’t been in touch with for two years is no longer a pool. People change jobs, move house or lose interest. So maintaining your list is just as important as building it up.
- Keep track of the status and date. For each candidate, make a note of when you last had contact with them and what their current situation is.
- Segment. Organise your talent pool by role, experience and availability, so that when a vacancy arises, you can immediately see the right group.
- Tidy up regularly. Remove people who are no longer responding from your active shortlist. Also check whether you are still permitted to retain their data; have this verified by the person within your organisation responsible for data protection.
- Keep adding new students. Without new recruits, the workforce is gradually ageing.
- Measure the yield. How many candidates come from the talent pool, and how quickly? You can find out how to measure this in Measuring recruitment campaign figures.
Make sure you appoint someone to be in charge. If no one is responsible, communication breaks down as soon as things get busy. And that’s exactly when you need the team.
Do it yourself or get some help?
Many employers recognise the value of a talent pool but do not have the time to manage campaigns, follow-ups and contact. FosFor combines data-driven recruitment campaigns with pre-selection and follow-up, from campaign to application. On average, clients interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. There are weekly strategic meetings to discuss campaigns, results and next steps. The final decision on who to hire remains with you. You can read about how this works in practice in our data-driven approach.
Do you have a role that keeps coming up? If so, it’s worth checking whether you really are starting from scratch every time. Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your recurring vacancy and your current approach.