Recruiting for niche roles: where can you find that small group of candidates?

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Are you looking for someone to fill a role that is so specific that job sites and standard recruitment campaigns yield almost no results? If so, you probably don’t have a reach problem, but a talent pool problem. The group of people who are exactly the right fit is small. Recruiting for niche roles therefore requires a different approach: first, clearly define which requirements are absolutely essential; then, target people who aren’t actively looking for work; and only then broaden your search to include related professions, regions and educational backgrounds.

In this article, you’ll learn how to identify a niche role, which sources actually yield candidates, and how to maintain high standards whilst broadening your search. We have separate articles for specific professions, such as ship’s electricians. Here, we’re focusing on the approach that works for extremely rare roles, regardless of the sector.

What makes a role a niche role rather than simply a scarce one?

‘Scarce’ and ‘niche’ may seem similar, but they require a different approach. The UWV refers to a shortage if there are more job vacancies than jobseekers in a particular profession. That says something about the relationship between supply and demand within an entire profession.

A niche role goes one step further. Not only is there a shortage of people in that profession, but the combination of requirements is so specific that very few people meet them at all. Think of a particular vocational qualification, experience with a specific installation or machine, and a certificate that very few people hold.

The UWV highlights a related issue: there is sometimes a mismatch between the skills jobseekers possess and the skills employers are looking for. Even if there are plenty of vacancies in a particular profession, many jobseekers may not have the right qualifications or experience. The more specific the requirements of your vacancy, the smaller the pool of suitable candidates.

A rare role Niche role
The crux of the problem More job vacancies than jobseekers in this profession A very specific set of requirements
Size of the target group More job vacancies than jobseekers within the profession A small group, some of whom are not actively looking
First question How can I stand out from other employers? Which requirements are actually set in stone, and where are these people?

Are you unsure which category your vacancy falls into? Then count your essential requirements. The more requirements that are mandatory at the same time, the smaller the remaining pool of candidates will be.

Why do job sites and standard campaigns yield such poor results?

A job site mainly reaches people who are actively looking for work at that moment. In the case of a niche role, it is unlikely that those few suitable professionals will be looking around this very week. Some of the suitable candidates are not actively looking and therefore cannot be reached solely via job boards. However, they may well be open to a move if the opportunity appeals to them.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

A standard campaign often faces the same problem. A broad target audience, generic copy and a short campaign duration result in few relevant responses when the pool of potential customers is small. A larger budget does not automatically solve this. It is better to check first whether your message resonates with what these specific people consider important.

Which sources do actually yield candidates?

The UWV explains that, when dealing with hard-to-fill vacancies, employers adapt and expand their recruitment process. They leave vacancies open for longer, advertise them through other channels, draw on their own network, offer training or engage an intermediary. Ultimately, according to the UWV, nearly two-thirds of those vacancies are filled after all. For a niche role, you can use these routes as follows:

1. People who aren’t actively looking, but are open to the idea

Some members of the small group who are suitable are not actively looking for work. You cannot reach these people through job boards alone. One approach is to run targeted campaigns in the places where they spend their time online, with a message that gives them a specific reason to make the switch. You can read about how this works in our article on reaching passive jobseekers.

2. Your own network and that of your staff

Ask your current colleagues who they know from their studies, previous employers or suppliers. In a small department, this can yield names that you wouldn’t find through job adverts. Make a note of who you contact, so that you don’t have to start from scratch the next time there’s a vacancy.

3. Related professions

The UWV states that employers are increasingly looking at skills when recruiting people from other sectors. Some professions require the same combination of key skills, so that you can also approach people from other professions. In the ‘Related Professions’ report, the UWV provides 10 examples of related professions for each of 17 hard-to-fill roles. For the technical sector, we have elaborated on this further in career changers entering the engineering sector.

4. Training or an intermediary

If the team is really too small, you could take on someone who already has a good grasp of the majority of the work and have them learn the rest in-house. Alternatively, you could opt for a provider that targets the specific audience. Both are options mentioned by the UWV; which one is suitable depends on how much time and support you can offer yourself.

How can you broaden the search radius without compromising on the functional requirements?

Broadening your search doesn’t mean lowering your standards. It means assessing each requirement to determine whether it’s essential from day one or can be learnt later. This way, you maintain quality whilst still expanding the pool of candidates.

  1. Break down your requirements. Place each requirement in one of three columns: legally or safety-related requirements, requirements needed within a few months, or desirable requirements. Only the first column is a strict requirement. Use our explanation of determine the knockout criteria to get that in focus.
  2. Look at skills rather than job titles. Which skills make a difference in the workplace? Then find out which other jobs require those same skills.
  3. Expand your region in a considered way. According to the UWV, employers may, due to commuter traffic, recruiting staff from a wider area than just their own region. Longer journey times can, however, have a negative impact on your work-life balance. So discuss in advance what you can do to counter this, such as an adjusted timetable or a travel expenses scheme, if this is possible within your organisation.
  4. Adapt your message to the new group. Someone changing careers wants to know what the induction process involves. An experienced professional from another region wants to know what benefits the move will bring.

When is a longer lead time realistic?

It is not possible to give a realistic timeframe in advance, and there is no general standard for niche roles in the source material. However, you can assess whether you need to allow for a longer process. This is likely to be the case if:

  • several strict requirements apply at the same time and you cannot defer any of them to the training phase;
  • virtually all the right people already have a job and need to be persuaded first;
  • you cannot extend the area, for example because the work takes place at a fixed location with a short journey time;
  • You opt for training, which means that someone is only fully operational once they have completed their induction.

For the vacancies that FosFor fills, the average turnaround time is between 3 and 8 weeks. With an extremely small candidate pool, this is an average, not a guarantee. Does the same niche role come up frequently? If so, it’s worth building up a pool of candidates on an ongoing basis, so you don’t have to start from scratch every time. Read how to build up a pool of candidates for recurring hard-to-fill vacancies.

Where are you starting tomorrow?

Start small and be specific. Write down your essential requirements, draw up a list of three related professions and determine how far your region realistically extends. Then identify where your current approach is falling short: is your reach too limited, does your offering not meet people’s needs, or are people dropping out of the process?

FosFor combines recruitment, data and marketing. Using target audience data, tools and AI, we identify where candidates are and what message resonates with them, and we continuously refine our campaigns based on results. On average, clients only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month, as we handle the pre-selection and guidance. Read more about our data-driven approach, or see how this works out for a specific profile in recruit ship’s electricians.

Are you struggling with a vacancy that’s getting hardly any applications? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll work out together where the small group of suitable candidates is.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.