Reassigning a candidate to another vacancy: here’s how to go about it

6 mins’ read time

Tadaah team meeting

A candidate comes in for your vacancy as a service engineer, but during the interview it becomes clear that he’s actually a better fit for that other vacancy as a work planner. What do you do then? The short answer: don’t immediately write the candidate off as unsuitable. First, check whether they really meet the requirements for that other role, discuss it openly with them and consult the second hiring manager before making any promises.

Reassigning a candidate to a different vacancy can provide you with a rare skill set that you would otherwise have lost. It does, however, require clear agreements. Otherwise, the candidate may feel as though they have been passed on, or two managers may assess the same person in different ways.

This article is about vacancies that are currently open, within the same recruitment round. Would you like to shortlist candidates for roles that will become available later? If so, our article on build up a pool of candidates for recurring hard-to-fill vacancies better.

How can you tell if a candidate is better suited to a different role?

You can often spot this by a mismatch on one or two key requirements, whilst motivation, attitude and some of their experience are actually good. This can become apparent as early as when scheduling an interview or during a telephone screening. Indeed also points this out: just because someone isn’t suitable for this particular role doesn’t mean they’re a no for the whole company. The advice is to see whether their skills or personality would be a good fit for another team or a different opportunity (Indeed).

Signs to look out for during a conversation:

  • Experience goes hand in hand with the role. Someone applies for a job as a mechanic, but mainly talks about planning, costing or management.
  • The candidate is asking questions that relate to a different role. For example, regarding customer contact in an internal technical support role.
  • The level isn’t right. Too senior or, conversely, too junior for this vacancy, but a good fit for another vacant post.
  • The requirements do not match. The working hours, commute or amount of field work don’t suit me, whereas another vacancy does meet those requirements.

Treat such an indication as a reason to ask further questions, not as a conclusion. A suspicion that someone might be a better fit elsewhere is only useful if you check it against the requirements of that other vacancy. If you work with a selection scorecard for hiring managers, then place the scorecard for the second role next to it.

How do you discuss a different role with the candidate?

Be honest about the first vacancy and make it clear that the second role is a serious option, not a consolation prize. Say what you see, ask if he’s interested, and don’t promise anything that hasn’t been agreed yet.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

A four-step conversation helps to prevent confusion:

  1. State the outcome for the first vacancy. For example: “For the technician role, you lack the experience in on-call duties that we require.”
  2. Please explain why you are considering a different role. Link it to what the candidate actually said, so that it isn’t just a random suggestion.
  3. Please explain what that role involves. Job description, working hours, location and terms of employment. Let him read the job advert.
  4. Ask him what he’d like to do and explain the next step. Who will get in touch, when, and what will happen to their application for the first role?

Be careful how you phrase things. “We might have something else for you” sounds vague. “I’d like to introduce you to the work planning manager, as your experience in planning would be a good fit there” is specific. If the candidate says no, respect that. There’s a reason they applied for that specific role.

Do you also recruit people through campaigns who aren’t actively looking for a job? In that case, a candidate has often responded because of a specific reason for wanting to change jobs, such as working hours or commute time. Check whether that reason still applies to the other role. You can read more about this target group in reaching passive jobseekers.

What level of coordination is required between hiring managers?

The second hiring manager must be able to assess for themselves whether the candidate is a good fit. A warm handover saves time, but does not replace their judgement. Agree in advance who will do what.

Subject What you agree on
Decision The manager of the second role makes decisions regarding that role, based on their own requirements.
Transfer Share your interview notes and scores, and explain why the candidate is not suitable for the first role.
Point of contact One person will liaise with the candidate to ensure they do not receive messages from two different sources.
Planning How soon should an interview for the second role take place, to ensure the candidate doesn’t lose interest?
Status in your system Is the candidate applying for both roles, or are you closing the first application?

That last row is more practical than you might think. How you record this varies depending on the recruitment system. In Greenhouse, for example, “add to another vacancy” creates a new application: the candidate can progress through both interview processes simultaneously, and the historical data is retained for both vacancies. According to Greenhouse, “transferring” a candidate is, in most cases, only intended if they have been accidentally linked to the wrong vacancy, and in doing so, certain details are lost (Greenhouse). Do you use a different system? If so, check what happens to notes and scores before you move a candidate.

Use the information from the first role as a guide, not as a substitute for your own assessment. If you want a clear understanding of what the second role entails, you can consult the intake questions for hiring managers have another go at it.

When is rehoming not advisable?

Reassignment isn’t worthwhile if the match with the other role is largely wishful thinking. In that case, a polite, prompt rejection is better for the candidate and for you.

It is better to opt for a rejection if:

  • the candidate does not meet a strict requirement for the second role, such as a required certificate or driving licence;
  • he states that he has no interest in the type of work, the rota or the location;
  • you are suggesting the other role mainly because you don’t want to turn the candidate down;
  • the second vacancy isn’t actually open yet, or the hiring manager doesn’t have time for it;
  • the difference in ability is so great that disappointment is inevitable after a few months.

A rejection doesn’t have to be the end of the story. Explain why it isn’t the right fit at the moment. And if you’d like to contact him later about a new vacancy, ask if that’s OK with him. You can find out how long you’re allowed to keep his details in Storing application data in accordance with the GDPR.

Here’s how to set this up in advance

Relocating works most smoothly if you don’t wait until the situation arises to think about it. A few points to agree on in advance:

  • Make sure interviewers are aware of which other vacancies are available and what the key requirements are.
  • Agree on who is authorised to put forward a candidate to another manager.
  • Discuss in your regular recruitment meetings which candidates might be better suited to other roles. A regular Agenda for the weekly recruitment meeting helps to ensure this isn’t left undone.
  • Make a note of how you record this in your system, so that no notes get lost.

At FosFor, we handle the initial selection process: we screen applications, conduct the first interviews and assess candidates on their motivation, experience and suitability for the organisation. In our weekly strategic meetings, we discuss campaigns, results and next steps. Would you like to see how it all works? Take a look at our data-driven approach.

Do you have several hard-to-fill vacancies open at the same time and would you like to know how to make better use of candidates across those roles? Discuss your job vacancies with us.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.