Outsourcing employer branding or doing it yourself – how do you choose?

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Are you torn between outsourcing employer branding and doing it yourself? Doing it yourself works if three conditions are met: someone actually has the time for it, you know your target audience well, and you can test your assumptions. If any one of these three is missing, external help will usually be more beneficial. This is particularly true for hard-to-fill vacancies, where an employer narrative that doesn’t resonate can hold you back for a long time.

It’s rarely a case of all or nothing. You can keep control of the story yourself and only outsource the parts where you lack the expertise, time or an objective perspective. Would you prefer to start on your own with limited resources? Then read first about how to Employer branding on a tight budget deals with. This article looks at when it’s best to seek help.

When can you take charge of employer branding yourself?

You can do this yourself if your employer brand is firmly established within your organisation and isn’t just given attention when there’s a vacancy. Take an honest look at these conditions:

  • Time and ownership. There is one person who is systematically allocated hours for this and is also held to account for it.
  • Knowledge of the target audience. You know from conversations with candidates and staff what your target group is looking for. What the management thinks does not count as evidence here.
  • In-house expertise in marketing and communications. You can translate a message into text, visuals and campaigns.
  • Measurability. You can see which message generates which responses, and what the quality of those responses is.

LinkedIn lists both routes as options: you can use our own marketing and communications department or outsource the work to an agency. If you don’t have that department, or if it’s already fully occupied with customer communications, then outsourcing is the more obvious option.

What are the signs that internal knowledge is not enough?

The clearest sign: you’re putting in a lot of effort, but the right people aren’t responding. In such cases, it’s often not down to the amount of effort you’re putting in, but to what you’re saying and to whom. If you recognise one or more of these situations, an outside perspective can be invaluable.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.
  • You’re getting responses, but not from your target audience. We do receive applications, but they are rarely suitable for the role.
  • Your story was devised in-house. HR or senior management have written the employer’s statement without input from staff or candidates.
  • You’re listing the same benefits as your competitors. A good salary, a great team and opportunities for career progression won’t set you apart if everyone else is promising the same.
  • Candidates drop out later in the process. They respond to your job advert, but turn you down after the first interview or when you make an offer. In that case, your promise probably doesn’t match up with what they’re experiencing.
  • Nobody knows what works. There is no clear picture of which message or which channel yields the best candidates.
  • You are recruiting from a new target group. Candidates coming from different backgrounds or with a different job profile require a different approach to the one you’re used to.

What does target audience data offer that internal assumptions do not?

Target audience data reveals what candidates in your role and market actually value, rather than what you think they value. These two often differ more than you might expect. Employers often believe that certain benefits are decisive, whilst the data shows that the target audience has different priorities.

Wide-ranging surveys help you to spot trends. Randstad’s employer brand surveys, for example, are based on more than 166,000 respondents and insights from more than 6,400 companies across 34 markets. Randstad combines global trends with local market insights. Such research tells you what employees generally value. It does not tell you what a welder, mechanic or account manager in your region expects from you, or how your offer compares with that of an employer further down the road.

You’ll need more specific data for that. You can see the difference below.

Internal recruitment What you can use target audience data to assess
“Our salary is the strongest argument.” What terms and conditions of employment and fringe benefits do candidates mention for this role, and how do you compare with your competitors?
“Our atmosphere speaks for itself.” Do candidates pick up on that tone in your communication, and is it a reason for them to respond?
“Everyone knows us.” Does your target audience know who you are and what you stand for, or do you mainly know yourself?
“The application process is fine.” At what stage in the process do candidates drop out, and why?

You can read more about what such data can reveal in An attractive employer: what the data really reveals. If you’d like to start doing your own research, the article on carry out a target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies.

Which aspects of employer branding are best suited to outsourcing?

Outsource anything that requires specialist knowledge, data or an independent perspective. Keep for yourself what only you can provide: knowledge of your workplace and the decisions about what you commit to. In practice, this division of responsibilities often works well:

Component Do it yourself Outsourcing
Target group and labour market analysis If you have access to data and the time to analyse it If you tend to rely mainly on your instincts or don’t have anything to compare it with
Competitive analysis An initial review of competitors’ job vacancies A systematic comparison of the offering and the message
Employer’s Perspective and EVP The question: what makes working at your organisation truly different? Refining and aligning with what the target audience is looking for
Staff stories Always deliver it yourself; nobody knows your workplace better Help with translating into content
Campaigns and measurement If you have the knowledge and time to make adjustments If you don’t know which message attracts which candidates
Candidate journey Carrying out follow-ups and conducting interviews yourself An analysis of where and why candidates drop out

The employer profile is a logical part of the process to work on together. According to LinkedIn, Branding experts help you refine your EVP and employer brand message so that they are accurate and consistent. The content must, however, be your own. You can read about how to draw up a job description for operational roles in Drawing up job descriptions for technical and blue-collar roles.

What’s always up to you: the choice of what terms and conditions of employment you offer, what you promise your candidates, and who you hire. An agency advises; you decide.

How can you ensure that an outsourced recruitment process remains aligned with your job adverts?

The biggest risk of outsourcing is a nice employer narrative that isn’t reflected anywhere. Candidates don’t read a brand document; they read your job advert and have interviews with your team. Gallup states that organisations should The employee value proposition must be tailored to what candidates are looking for, and these elements must be embedded in their recruitment practices. Here’s how to go about it:

  1. Make job advertisement texts part of the brief. Agree in advance that the process is only complete once the message has been included in your job adverts.
  2. Involve staff in the role. Research by Indeed shows that However, around 8% of the respondents ask colleagues in a similar role to help draft job advertisements, whilst that involvement helps to refine the requirements. They know which skills really matter in the role.
  3. Adapt the story to suit each role. An EVP isn’t just a text to be copied. For each role, explain in concrete terms what it means for someone who comes to work for you. You’ll find tips on how to do this in Using target audience data for your job advertisement.
  4. Assess the whole process, not just the advert. Does what you promise match up with how you follow up with candidates, how interviews are conducted and what you offer?
  5. Arrange regular meetings. Discuss regularly what the campaigns are delivering and what adjustments you need to make. At FosFor, this takes place during a weekly strategic meeting to discuss campaigns, results and next steps.
  6. Focus on quality. Don’t just look at the number of responses, but focus above all on how many candidates are suitable.

Do it yourself, outsource it or a mix of both: a quick check

Answer these five questions with ‘yes’ or ‘no’. The more often you say ‘no’, the more you’ll benefit from external help.

  • Is there anyone within your organisation who is systematically allocated time to work on your employer brand?
  • Do you know – based on data, not just a hunch – what matters to your target audience?
  • Do you know how your offering compares to that of your competitors?
  • Can you gauge which message attracts the right candidates?
  • Is your employer’s story reflected in your job adverts, interviews and job offers?

Many employers opt for a hybrid approach: handling the narratives and decisions in-house, whilst outsourcing the data, assessment and campaigns. FosFor combines recruitment, data and marketing, and advises on terms of employment and employer positioning based on target audience data. We go beyond mere advice: we guide you through every stage, from campaign to application and follow-up. You can read about how this works, step by step, in our data-driven approach.

Are you unsure which parts you can handle yourself and where it would be worth getting some help? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your hard-to-fill vacancy. We’ll then work together to identify where your employer brand is currently falling short.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.