Is the same job vacancy posted online for the third time this year? If so, you probably don’t have a vacancy problem, but a recruitment problem. You need a recruitment strategy if vacancies keep reappearing, the quality of applicants varies significantly from round to round, and you’re not quite sure what matters most to your target audience.
Not every challenging vacancy requires a strategy. Sometimes a role is difficult to fill on a one-off basis, and a well-written job advert is enough. Below, you can read about how to tell the difference. You’ll also find out what signs indicate that simply posting one-off vacancies no longer works.
Occasional or structural: what’s the difference?
An occasional recruitment problem has a clear cause and will pass. A structural problem keeps recurring, even if you change the job advertisement, the job title or the recruitment channel.
The UWV points out that a temporary increase in job vacancies may arise as a result of business expansion, the replacement of staff who are leaving or retiring, or new projects. According to the UWV, this means that it does not necessarily mean that there is a structural deficit. Job vacancies that remain unfilled for a long time due to a lack of suitable candidates may well be an indicator of a structural shortage in that profession. The UWV always assesses this in conjunction with the number of jobseekers.
Applied to your own organisation, the difference looks like this:
| Characteristic | An occasional problem | Structural problem |
|---|---|---|
| Reason | One person leaving, a new project or temporary growth | No obvious reason, or always the same one |
| Revision | One-off | The same function keeps cropping up |
| Effect of adjustments | A better text or a different channel often helps | Adjustments yield little or mixed results |
| Quality of responses | Fairly predictable | Varies considerably from round to round |
| Understanding the target audience | You know why candidates choose you | You recruit mainly on the basis of gut feeling and assumptions |
Seven signs that you need a recruitment strategy
Do you recognise two or more of these signs? If so, the problem is probably not with a single job vacancy, but with the way you recruit.
1. The same job vacancies keep reappearing
Technician, operator, account manager: if you keep advertising the same role every quarter, you’re just treating the symptom. There’s often something underlying the issue. Think of staff turnover, a job description that isn’t a good fit, or a message that attracts the wrong sort of people.
2. Not enough responses, even after making changes
You’re not alone in this. A study by the UWV states that 87%: employers are not responding enough to job vacancies as the reason for their recruitment difficulties. Is there still no response after you’ve adjusted your text, headline and channel? If so, the cause usually lies deeper than the advert itself.
3. The calibre of applicants varies considerably
According to the same UWV survey, employers with hard-to-fill vacancies report more frequently than in 2023 that applicants lack the right skills (64%), professional knowledge (59%) or work experience (55%). Do you find that one round of interviews yields suitable candidates, whilst the next round mainly produces mismatches? If so, you’re not quite sure which message attracts which people. If you’d like to get to the bottom of this, read how to measure the quality of your pool of applicants.
4. You don’t know what matters to your target audience
Employers often think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group actually has different priorities. If you cannot explain why an operator or sales assistant would choose to work for you, then you are writing your job adverts based on assumptions. Terms and conditions also play a part here: according to the UWV, for 36% of employers with hard-to-fill vacancies, recruitment difficulties are linked to applicants’ salary expectations.
5. You don’t know who you’re competing against
Candidates compare your job vacancy with those of other employers in their local area and sector. If you don’t know who they are and what they offer, you won’t be able to position your offer effectively. A competitive analysis of the labour market shows where you excel and where you fall short.
6. Candidates drop out between applying and the interview
You do get some responses, but people don’t reply to your phone call or turn up. That means you lose candidates during the process itself, not during the recruitment stage. Take a look at the the main causes of drop-off in the candidate journey to see where you’re going wrong.
7. You cannot say what a job vacancy has yielded
If you don’t know which channel generated the most applications, how many responses you needed, or what each placement cost, then you won’t be able to do any better next time round than you did last time. Without measuring your results, every job vacancy remains a new gamble.
Why a bigger budget or extra channels don’t always solve the problem
The first reaction to a difficult vacancy is often: to broaden the reach. The UWV has observed that, when it comes to vacancies that are difficult to fill, employers mainly adapt and expand the recruitment process. They leave vacancies open for longer, advertise them through other channels, draw on their network, offer training or engage an intermediary. Ultimately, according to the UWV, they manage to fill nearly two-thirds of these vacancies after all.
That’s a logical reaction. But increasing the reach of a message that doesn’t resonate simply results in more of the same. A bigger budget increases the number of people who see your job advert. It doesn’t change whether those people feel it speaks to them.
SHRM identifies a few root causes that lead to advertising budgets for job vacancies often yield too little:
- not knowing how many applicants you need to find one good candidate;
- job adverts that don’t work;
- no strategy behind the advertising;
- not a yardstick for measuring results.
Three of those four points are not about the channel itself, but about the approach surrounding it. That is precisely where the difference lies between running campaigns and having a strategy. Read more the difference between recruitment marketing and recruitment strategy if you want to know what question is on your mind.
When should you have labour market data analysed?
Analysing data makes sense as soon as you start making decisions that you no longer want to base on gut feeling. That moment usually comes sooner than employers realise. Common examples include:
- Before you increase the budget or add a channel. Finding out why it isn’t working at the moment will prevent you from spending extra money on the same problem.
- When adjustments no longer yield any results. If you’ve already changed your text, title and channel without seeing any difference, then you’re lacking insight into your target audience or your competitors.
- If you have to continue filling the same role on a permanent basis. When a business is growing or staff turnover is high, it pays to find out once and for all what works, rather than starting from scratch every time.
- When the discussion about conditions revolves around assumptions. If one manager says it’s about pay and another says it’s about working hours, then target group data can help answer that question.
You can get quite a long way just using public sources. Find out which ones labour market data you can use without expensive tools. If you want to link that data to target audience insights and a competitive analysis, having it analysed is a logical next step.
FosFor does this using data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, target audience data and public labour market data. This informs its advice on what your target audience really values, from terms of employment to communication and the application process. In our data-driven approach You’ll find out how this analysis ties in with campaigns and the initial selection.
Your first step: look back at your last three job vacancies
Take the last three job vacancies that proved difficult and ask yourself four questions for each one:
- Was there a clear, one-off trigger?
- Have I disabled this feature at any point over the past year?
- Do I know why the successful candidate chose us?
- Do I know which channel and what message that candidate produced?
If you answer ‘no’ to question 1 and ‘yes’ to question 2, or if you are unable to answer questions 3 and 4, then simply posting individual job vacancies is probably no longer enough. Would you like to discuss what lies behind your hard-to-fill vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting, then we’ll look at your situation together before you decide on a course of action.