You’ve come up with a new role. Perhaps for a new department, a role that combines two existing responsibilities, or a title that no one in the company has held before. In that case, you’re missing everything you’d normally rely on: a previous job advertisement, a former employee as a benchmark, and figures on what has worked in the past.
Still, you don’t have to take a guess. If you want to recruit for a new role with no track record, you can borrow that track record from similar roles elsewhere in the market. You look at what people in those roles do, what they know and how they describe themselves. Based on that, you can define your target audience, your job requirements and your recruitment channels.
This requires a different order to the one you’re used to. Below, you can read about where the difference lies, how to find similar functions, and which risks you can mitigate in advance.
Why recruiting for a new role is different
With a recurring vacancy, you have a point of reference. You know who performed well, which text generated responses and where things often went wrong in the process. With a new role, none of that is available.
- No profile to view: No one within your organisation has ever held that role.
- No historical recruitment data: You don’t know how many responses are realistic or which message will strike a chord.
- No shared image: The hiring manager, senior management and HR often each have their own idea of what the role entails.
- No recognisable name: The title is often devised internally and means little to candidates.
Many employers underestimate this last point. A role that sounds logical from an internal perspective may be unrecognisable to candidates. And anyone who doesn’t recognise themselves in your job advert will simply click away.
Decide on the content first, then choose the title
Without an internal point of reference, the job description is your only guide. So start with the tasks and work your way up to the requirements from there. The job title comes later.
The Office of Personnel Management states that Job analysis: the basis for all assessment and selection decisions. You analyse the tasks a person carries out, the skills required to perform them, and how the two are linked. When creating a new role, this is not just a formality. It is the way to ensure you do not set out requirements that nobody can justify.
How to refine the job requirements
- List the most important tasks. As specifically as possible: what does this person do on a typical Tuesday?
- Link the knowledge or skill required to each task. If a requirement has no associated task, you should either remove it or list it under ‘bonus’.
- Distinguish between what someone needs to be able to do on day one and what you can teach them. When you start a new job, that second list is often longer than you think.
- Decide what success will look like after six months. That way, you have a benchmark, even if there’s no one internally to compare it with.
- Ask everyone involved to respond individually. Compare the differences side by side and sort them out now, rather than waiting until after the first meeting.
Would you like to make this conversation with the hiring manager more focused? If so, use this Questions for a thorough initial consultation.
Use similar roles as a benchmark
Once the responsibilities are clear, you look for roles on the market that are most similar. These comparable roles provide what you’re missing internally: an established target audience, standard job titles and an idea of what candidates expect.
A useful framework is provided by O*NET, an occupational classification system. To to identify related professions O*NET looks at three things: what people do in a job, what they know and what they are called. You can use these three criteria yourself as well.
| Entrance | Question you’re asking | What it delivers |
|---|---|---|
| Tasks | Which existing roles involve largely the same duties? | A target group that is already doing this work, possibly under a different name |
| Knowledge | Where do people acquire the knowledge required for your role? | Training programmes, sectors and career change pathways to be established |
| Titles | What do people who do this sort of work call themselves? | Keywords for your job title and your targeting |
A new role often turns out to be a combination of two or three existing roles. In that case, you have several potential target groups. Make a conscious decision on a main approach: usually the group that has already mastered the most difficult tasks to learn.
What market data you collect
For each comparable role, gather whatever information you can find: job vacancies from other employers, the job titles and requirements they specify, the terms of employment they mention, and how scarce the profile is. Sources for this information can be found in which labour market data you can use without expensive tools.
With a labour market competition analysis You’ll then see where you can set yourself apart from other employers who are all vying for the same candidates.
What are the risks of an unclear job title?
A title you’ve made up yourself is a major risk when creating a new role. Candidates search for and scan job adverts for words they recognise. A title that only makes sense within your organisation will attract the wrong people – or no one at all.
Research shows just how much a title conveys. In a NBER working paper from 2016, based on data from the job site CareerBuilder.com, job titles accounted for more than 90% of the variation in salary for job adverts that specified a salary. Job titles also accounted for more than 80 per cent of the differences between job vacancies in terms of applicants’ education and experience. Although the study is based on data from a single job board, it clearly demonstrates how much a job title reveals about who applies.
It is no coincidence that O*NET maintains a separate list of alternative, everyday job titles … designed to improve keyword searches. For you, this means: translate your internal name into the words that candidates actually use.
- Too vague: A job title like ‘specialist operations’ can mean all sorts of things. You get responses that don’t quite fit.
- Too heavy or too light: If the role sounds more senior than it actually is, it creates false expectations. If it sounds too lightweight, experienced people will lose interest.
- Untraceable: Nobody searches for a title that only you have.
- Vague content: If the duties listed in the job vacancy remain unclear, candidates will be unable to assess whether the role is a good fit for them.
A practical solution: choose a distinctive headline and explain in the first few sentences of the job advert what makes the role different.
How do you adapt similar roles to a specific target audience and channel?
By looking at similar roles, you can get a clear picture of your target audience. Where do these people currently work, what are they looking for in their next job, and how actively are they looking? Only then should you choose your channels.
There’s a pitfall here. When filling a new role, employers often fill in the gaps in their knowledge with assumptions about what candidates find appealing. Employers frequently believe that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group actually has different preferences. You can read about how to incorporate such insights into your text in Using target audience data for your job advertisement.
When choosing a channel, the rule is: follow your target audience, not your own habits. If the majority of your target audience isn’t actively looking, there’s little point in using channels that are only viewed by jobseekers. It’s better to test a few approaches side by side and adjust your strategy based on what the first few weeks reveal.
So think of your first campaign as a trial run. That way, you can still build up the track record you were missing. After the first few weeks, keep an eye on:
- Do the profiles match what you would expect based on similar roles?
- Which title and which message attract the most appropriate responses?
- At what stage do candidates drop out: at the advert, the job description or the initial contact?
- Are your job requirements appropriate, or does a particular requirement turn out to be an unnecessary hurdle in practice?
Help with a function without an internal reference point
FosFor combines recruitment, data and marketing. Its approach is based on data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, target audience data and public labour market data. It is precisely when you have nothing internally to compare with that it helps to be able to draw on that broader knowledge.
The decision on who to hire is entirely up to you. FosFor handles the shortlisting and support: on average, clients only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates each month. During a weekly strategic meeting, you’ll discuss campaigns, results and next steps. You can read about how this works in our data-driven approach.
Are you about to advertise a new vacancy and are you unsure about the job title, target audience or channel? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your situation before the first advert goes live.