Your recruitment process is underway, candidates are through to the second round, and then the news comes: the vacancy is being put on hold, or withdrawn altogether. A budget freeze, a reorganisation, or an internal candidate who ends up getting the role after all. What do you do then with the people who are already in the running? The short answer: first, determine internally whether this is a temporary pause or a permanent halt; then, inform everyone in the pipeline quickly and honestly; and only ask for explicit permission to keep candidates on file for a similar role at a later date.
Withdrawing a job vacancy is not the same as rejecting an individual candidate. The candidate has done nothing wrong; you are changing the rules of the game. That is precisely why an applicant pays close attention to how you communicate this.
A break or a permanent halt: ensure internal clarity first
The biggest mistake is communicating before you yourself know what’s going on. If you tell candidates that the vacancy is “on hold for the time being” and it turns out a week later that it’s been scrapped for good, you’ll have to deliver bad news twice. That erodes trust more than a single clear message.
So, before you ring or email anyone, ask yourself these questions:
- Will this feature be brought back, or has it been discontinued for good?
- If it’s a break: is there a specific moment when you make the decision again?
- Is there a possibility of a similar role becoming available in another department or at another location?
- Who is the point of contact for candidates, and who decides on a re-start?
If you are unable to answer the first two questions, that in itself is information. You can tell candidates honestly that the decision is still pending and when you will know more. That is better than making a vague promise that you will later have to go back on.
How do you communicate that a vacancy has been withdrawn?
Communicate as soon as possible once the decision has been finalised, in person where possible, and provide a clear, general explanation of the reasons. You do not need to share internal details about budgets or reorganisations. However, “the vacancy has been withdrawn due to a change in organisational requirements” is much easier for a candidate to understand than silence or a standard email.
How quickly candidates hear back from you plays a part in how they perceive your organisation. In our article on the the main causes of drop-off in the candidate journey You can see that silence and a lack of clarity about the next step are recurring sources of friction. The same applies when a vacancy is withdrawn: for a candidate, hearing nothing feels worse than receiving bad news.
Candidates who have already had an interview
This group has invested time and energy in you. They may have taken time off work for an interview or even turned down another opportunity. You should therefore ideally ring them, and then send a brief email to confirm.
It is standard practice for organisations to inform all candidates with whom they have held interviews of the outcome. For example, the UK government states, in relation to a recruitment process for a scientific advisory committee, that all candidates interviewed will be informed of the outcome, providing feedback where possible. This relates to one specific procedure, but the principle can be applied more broadly: anyone who has had an interview will hear from you personally.
During that meeting, discuss the following:
- What has been decided: a break or a permanent halt.
- That the decision says nothing about the candidate themselves.
- Whether and when you get in touch again.
- Whether the candidate is open to a similar role in the future, and whether you are permitted to retain their details for that purpose.
Candidates who have only applied
For applicants who have not been invited for an interview, a brief, personalised email is usually sufficient. Some application systems can do this automatically. In the UK government’s online job vacancy system, setting the status to “Campaign Withdrawn” candidates an email stating that the vacancy has been withdrawn. Check in your own system which messages are sent automatically, to ensure the text is correct and that no one receives two conflicting emails.
A temporary break: how can you avoid causing unnecessary concern?
During a recruitment hiatus, it is tempting to “keep candidates interested” with an optimistic message. Only do this if that optimism is well-founded. A candidate who waits months for a role that never materialises will later share that story with colleagues in the sector. In sectors where everyone knows one another, such as engineering or the maritime sector, word of such an experience can spread quickly.
You can see the difference in approach in this overview:
| Situation | What you communicate | Follow-up appointment |
|---|---|---|
| Temporary pause with a decision point | The vacancy is on hold until a specific date; the candidate is free to explore other options | Please get in touch by or before that time, even if no decision has yet been made |
| A break without a decision point | It’s true that the future of the role is uncertain | In practice, treat it as a ‘stop’ and ask if you can get in touch later |
| Permanent closure | The vacancy is being withdrawn, with a general explanation given | Only request permission to retain data if there is a realistic prospect of a similar role |
If you’re taking a break from the recruitment process, make a point of giving candidates the freedom to apply elsewhere. That may sound counterintuitive, but it takes the pressure off and shows that you’re taking their situation seriously.
When do you shortlist candidates for a similar role?
Only retain candidates’ details if there is a realistic chance of a suitable role becoming available, and only with their consent. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, it is standard practice to delete the details of an applicant who was not offered the role no later than four weeks after the end of the recruitment process. Job applicants can give their consent for their data to be retained for a longer period, for example because a suitable post may become available at a later date. The regulator considers a period of up to one year following the conclusion of the proceedings to be reasonable in this regard.
Such consent must meet certain requirements. The AP sets out four conditions: given freely, unambiguously, in full knowledge of the facts and specifically. In practice, this means: ask explicitly, explain why and for how long you will retain the data, and make it clear that saying “no” will have no consequences. You can read more about retention periods in how long you are allowed to keep job application details under the GDPR.
A few questions can help you decide whether it is worth keeping something:
- Do you often look for this type of role, for example, fitters or operators who regularly feature in your staff rota?
- Was the candidate strong enough to approach him again without going through the process all over again?
- Can you give a specific reason for getting in touch within the retention period?
If the answer is ‘yes’ more often than not, then this forms part of a broader approach. In our article on a build up a pool of candidates for recurring hard-to-fill vacancies you’ll find out how to organise this on a structural basis.
A practical checklist for moving out or taking a break
As well as interviews with candidates, there are a few practical matters that are easily overlooked:
- Stop the influx. Take the vacancy offline and pause any active adverts. In the British system mentioned earlier, simply changing the status does not prevent new applications from being submitted as long as the external advert is still live. You should therefore also check that your adverts, job sites and ‘Careers’ page have actually been updated.
- Make one person the owner. Having a single point of contact prevents candidates from hearing conflicting accounts from the recruiter and the line manager.
- Make a note of what you have agreed. For each candidate, note down what has been communicated and whether consent has been given for data retention, including the retention period.
- Plan the next steps. If there is a break, make a note of the decision date in the diary so that candidates are not forgotten.
- Give a brief assessment. Look back and see whether the decision could have been foreseen earlier. This will prevent you from launching your next campaign before the role has actually been finalised internally. The same applies to the adjusting a recruitment campaign That’s where that question belongs.
If you work with a recruitment partner, agree in advance who will inform candidates when a vacancy is closed. At FosFor, our support covers everything from the campaign through to applications and follow-up, and we discuss the campaigns, results and next steps in a weekly strategic meeting. Having a fixed time for this helps to ensure that any changes to the vacancy are brought to the table in good time.
Would you like to know how we organise campaigns, shortlisting and follow-up? Then take a look at our data-driven approach. Or discuss your vacancy Feel free to get in touch with us if you’d like to discuss how best to manage the candidates in your current pipeline.