Adjusting a recruitment campaign: when and what should you change?

8 mins’ reading time

Tadaah team meeting

Your campaign has been running for a few weeks, the first figures are coming in, and they’re disappointing. Or perhaps not quite: lots of clicks, but few useful responses. The question then isn’t whether you should take action, but when and where.

The short answer: you should adjust your recruitment campaign as soon as a trend persists long enough to be recognised as a pattern, and you can pinpoint at which stage of the funnel things are going wrong. A problem with reach requires a different approach to a problem with the quality of responses. So change one thing at a time, give it time, and then reassess the situation.

You can find out exactly which figures you are measuring and what they mean in What the figures from your recruitment campaign reveal. This article is about the next step: which adjustment corresponds to which signal?

Which interim indicators justify a change?

A disappointing figure is not in itself a reason to take action. A signal only becomes useful once you can link it to a cause. So find out where in the funnel candidates are dropping out: are they not seeing your advert, are they not clicking through, are they not applying, or are the wrong people applying?

The overview below will help you make that assessment. These are not strict thresholds, as what is considered normal varies depending on the role, target audience and channel. You should therefore compare your figures with those from previous weeks of the same campaign or with similar campaigns.

Signal Probable cause First amendment
Few screenings; the budget is not being spent Target group or region defined too narrowly Expand the target group or scope of work
High number of impressions, low click-through rate The message may not be resonating, or the targeting isn’t reaching the right people Check the targeting and display context, then adjust the headline, opening line or image
Good click-through rate, few applications Landing page or application step not working Check the application threshold and landing page
Plenty of responses, but few suitable candidates The targeting or message attracts the wrong people Refine the target audience, clarify the requirements
Budget runs out quickly when results are good Demand exceeds your budget Increase or reallocate the budget

Some of these patterns are confirmed by the platforms themselves. Google states in its help with budgets Two scenarios: if your budget is running out quickly whilst you’re generating conversions at a reasonable cost, a higher budget can help meet the extra demand. If, on the other hand, you’re spending significantly less than your budget allows, you can expand your keywords or add locations to reach more people.

Google also points out that a high bounce rate can be caused by a poor-quality landing page, and that this can affect both your click-through rate and your conversion rate. If people do click through but leave the page straight away, the problem is often not with the advert itself. Source: Google Ads Help on campaign performance.

What do you adjust first: your target audience, your message or your channel budget?

Start by identifying where the funnel is leaking. There’s little point in rewriting your message if the right people aren’t even seeing your advert. Conversely, increasing your budget won’t solve anything if the people you reach aren’t clicking.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

In its explanation of performance reports The same line of thinking: cost per click and cost per application show how your budget translates into interest and completed applications. If these costs are high, you can experiment with the title, description, targeting or budget to reach more relevant candidates. Which button you use first depends on the signal.

Adjust target audience

Adjust the target audience if your reach is too small or if you’re mainly getting responses from people who aren’t a good fit. In the first case, broaden your criteria: a greater travel distance, related roles or candidates from other sectors. In the second case, narrow your focus, for example by region or job title.

You can find out how to do this by region and role without wasting the budget in Job vacancy targeting by region and role.

Edit message

If you’re seeing lots of impressions but few clicks, your advert may not be resonating with your target audience. First, check that you’re reaching the right people: is the targeting correct, and in what context is your advert being shown? If that looks fine, try testing a different headline, an opening line or a different image. This is different from rewriting your entire job advert: you’re changing the hook, not the whole story.

This is often where the problem lies. Employers think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target audience actually has different priorities. If you focus your advert on a benefit that holds little appeal for the target audience, this could be one of the reasons for a low click-through rate. In that case, try a different selling point that appeals to the target audience, such as working hours, commute or the type of work.

Reallocate the budget

Budget is the last button, not the first. Only allocate budget to a channel or advert once it has demonstrably performed better in terms of suitable applications, not just clicks. Allocating more money to a campaign that attracts the wrong people will only result in more unsuitable responses.

How can you avoid jumping to the conclusion too soon that a campaign isn’t working?

One pitfall when adjusting a recruitment campaign is to make changes too quickly and too frequently. For Google Ads campaigns where the bidding strategy is set to ‘Learning’, the system needs time to optimise bids following a major change. Whether other channels have a similar learning period varies by platform; check this in the documentation for the channel you are using.

Google recommends waiting 7 to 14 days after launching a campaign, or after making significant changes to bids, adverts or targeting, before assessing performance or re-optimising. This advice applies to Google Ads campaigns with a bidding strategy that is in the learning phase; other channels operate differently. However, the principle is more widely applicable: give a change time to take effect before you make a judgement.

A few rules of thumb to avoid jumping to conclusions:

  • Change one variable at a time. If you adjust both your target audience and your message at the same time, you won’t know which one made the difference.
  • Look at trends, not individual days. One bad day doesn’t mean much. A decline over several weeks, however, does.
  • Please allow for delays. Not everyone applies straight away after clicking. Some candidates come back later.
  • Judge on the basis of quality. Fewer job applications can be a good thing if the proportion of suitable candidates increases. You can find out how to measure this in measuring the quality of your pool of applicants.

Waiting too long is also a risk. A recruitment campaign that fails to produce a suitable candidate for weeks costs you time and leaves a vacancy unfilled. The aim, therefore, is not to intervene as little as possible, but to intervene at the right moment, for a clear reason.

What role does weekly coordination play in making timely adjustments?

Weekly reviews ensure that any issues are addressed promptly. Google recommends reviewing your campaign performance at least once a week and setting up conversion tracking so that you can see what happens after someone clicks on your advert. See the Google’s explanation of campaign monitoring.

A weekly cycle is also a good rhythm for recruitment. Short enough to spot a disappointing trend in good time, long enough to allow a change to take effect. And you don’t just discuss the advertising figures, but also what happens after the application: were candidates followed up on quickly, did they fit in during the interview, and at what stage did they drop out?

A good weekly meeting answers three questions:

  1. How does this week compare with last week?
  2. Where in the funnel is the biggest bottleneck?
  3. Which one change are we making, and when will we review it?

Record that adjustment, noting the date and your expectations. That way, you can see a week later whether the change made a difference, and you’ll build up your knowledge for future campaigns. You’ll find a practical framework for this meeting in the agenda for a weekly recruitment meeting.

How FosFor organises its course corrections

At FosFor, weekly strategic meetings to discuss campaigns, results and next steps are a standard part of the process. We base our decisions on data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, target audience data and public labour market data, and we continuously optimise campaigns based on their performance.

You remain in control of who you hire. We take care of the shortlisting and guidance, so that, on average, you only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. Vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average, depending on the role and target group. You can read more about our approach at our data-driven approach.

Is your campaign up and running, and are you unsure what changes to make?

Start with one question: where is your funnel leaking? Compare your figures from the past few weeks, identify the cause of the biggest bottleneck and choose one change to make. Give it some time, then reassess.

Are you struggling to find a solution, or would you like someone to help you review a recruitment campaign for a hard-to-fill vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss together what signs you’re noticing and what action is appropriate in each case.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.