After weeks of searching, you’ve finally found a ship’s electrician, service engineer or experienced operator to interview. The candidate is a good fit, but is asking for more than your salary structure allows. How much leeway do you give them? The short answer: give leeway within a range that you have determined and justified before the interview. Deviating from your standard structure may be justifiable in the case of a genuinely scarce profile. This only works if you can explain the reason – one that is fair to comparable colleagues – and if you don’t try to solve everything with salary alone.
In this article, you will find out when flexibility is justifiable, what risks you run if you go too far, how to prevent imbalances, and what role benchmark data plays. We have deliberately chosen not to mention any specific figures. These depend on your role, region, collective agreement and existing pay scale.
When is it justifiable to deviate from your salary structure?
A fixed pay structure provides clarity. Everyone knows where they stand, and it prevents arbitrariness. Yet that structure is not set in stone. The central government states that employees must receive equal pay for work of equal value, and that this applies to all components: salary, bonuses, allowances and fringe benefits. Employers may only deviate from this if they have a valid reason. According to the Central Government on equal treatment in the workplace For example, in a tight labour market, an employer may offer a higher wage to attract new employees.
Scarcity can therefore be a valid reason. But ‘this candidate wants more’ is not, in itself, sufficient justification. Ask yourself these questions beforehand:
- Can you demonstrate that this profile is difficult to find, for example because the vacancy has been open for a long time or because previous candidates turned down the offer?
- Does this candidate have the knowledge, qualifications or experience that the role actually requires, rather than just ‘nice-to-haves’?
- Would you also allow the same deviation for another candidate with the same profile?
- Will you still be able to explain the reason to a colleague or manager a year from now?
By way of comparison: in the United Kingdom, it is stated that Acas An example in which an employer, in an equal pay case, may have to demonstrate that certain qualifications and skills are essential for the role and that it was difficult to recruit and retain staff for that role. This is UK law and is not directly applicable in the Netherlands. It does, however, illustrate the questions you might ask yourself: is the reason demonstrable, and is it unrelated to characteristics such as gender or age? If you are unsure about the legal aspects, seek advice from an employment law specialist.
What role does salary benchmark data play in the discussion?
Benchmark data tells you where your offer stands in relation to the market. Without that data, you’re negotiating on a hunch, and in such cases, it’s often the person who sounds the most confident who wins. With data, you can calmly explain why your offer is what it is, or decide that you need to be more flexible.
The British HR institute, the CIPD, explains that job evaluation and market benchmarking help you to gather internal and external data on roles within your own organisation and comparable roles at other employers. According to the CIPD factsheet on job evaluation and market pricing A sound interpretation of that data is required to ensure fair and competitive remuneration, and you must review those analyses regularly to ensure they remain in line with changes in roles, work and business needs.
For your negotiations, this means two things. Look externally: what do similar employers in your region offer for this role? And look internally: where does this role fit within your own pay scale? You can read about how to set up a benchmark and which sources you can use in our article on salary benchmarks in engineering.
Please note: a benchmark is a snapshot. If your data is out of date, a candidate may well be capable of more than your figures suggest. You should therefore check that your benchmarks are still up to date before starting the recruitment process.
What are the risks associated with too much flexibility?
Going along with it feels like the safe option at the time. You don’t want to lose this candidate. However, there are risks involved in giving them free rein without a clear framework.
You’re setting a precedent
What you do for one candidate becomes the new standard for the next. If you keep pushing the boundaries with every hard-to-fill role, after just a few recruitment drives you’ll no longer have a structure, but a collection of ad hoc arrangements.
You’re solving the wrong problem
Salary is important, but rarely the only thing that matters. Our target group data for technical staff shows that certainty of working hours, travelling time, training budget and working atmosphere are often at least as important. Employers often assume that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group has different priorities. A pay rise may be necessary, but if the underlying problem is chaotic rota planning or excessive workload, you’re essentially buying time. Read more about which consider operators’ terms and conditions of employment to be really important.
You’re negotiating with yourself
Without a pre-determined upper limit, there is a good chance that you will gradually move further along during the discussion. You should therefore agree internally who is authorised to make decisions and up to what point. That way, the chairperson won’t have to improvise.
How can you avoid creating an imbalance in your relationships with existing colleagues?
This is often the trickiest part. A new colleague who earns more than someone who has been doing the same job for years is bound to stand out. Salaries rarely remain a secret, and the disparity can undermine trust in your organisation.
A few practical tips:
- State the reason. Make a note of why you’re deviating: what qualifications, what shortages, what market data. That way, you’ll be able to explain your decision later.
- Take a look at the current team straight away. If the market rate for this role is higher than you thought, the same is likely to be true for your current staff. In that case, discuss whether the pay scale itself needs adjusting.
- Where possible, choose a temporary or conditional form. Consider an arrangement linked to a certification or a role expansion, provided that it applies to everyone in the same situation.
- Treat equal work equally. An argument based on scarcity must never be a disguised way of rewarding people unequally on the basis of personal characteristics.
Do you find that you have to make exceptions time and again for the same role? If so, that’s a sign that your structure is no longer in line with the market. You can’t solve this on a candidate-by-candidate basis; you need to review your remuneration policy.
How to determine your room for negotiation before the meeting
The best way to negotiate a salary when candidates are in short supply starts right from the initial screening stage of the vacancy. This step-by-step guide will help you give some leeway without losing control:
- Determine the bandwidth. Set out what you offer as standard and how far you are prepared to go in exceptional circumstances.
- Support your argument with data. Combine external market data with your internal pay scale.
- Agree on decision-making authority. Who is authorised to approve an exemption, and how quickly?
- Come up with some alternatives. What other benefits can you offer that this target group would appreciate, such as a predictable timetable or training opportunities?
- Keep asking questions during the conversation. Ask the candidate what is the deciding factor for them. A higher salary expectation may also be about security or recognition.
- Make up your mind quickly. In-demand candidates won’t wait weeks for clarity. Speed is part of your overall proposition.
Are candidates still turning down offers after receiving one? If so, have a look at our article on how to reduce the likelihood of a candidate turning down your job offer, and the Four mistakes that cost you your best candidates.
Creating space with a plan
Flexibility when dealing with hard-to-find candidates isn’t a bad thing. It only becomes a problem if you improvise on a case-by-case basis during each interview. By setting a predetermined range, using up-to-date data and having a clear justification, you can allow for flexibility where it is justifiable whilst keeping your team balanced.
FosFor advises organisations on what a specific target group really values, from terms and conditions of employment and fringe benefits to communication and the recruitment process. Would you like to know how we use target group data and labour market data? Read more about our data-driven approach. If you’re unsure about your offer for a hard-to-fill role, discuss your vacancy then feel free to get in touch with us, with no obligation.