The interview went well, there was a good rapport and your team is enthusiastic. A few days later, however, the candidate decides to turn the offer down. With profiles in engineering, production, logistics, sales or the maritime sector in short supply, this is particularly painful. The next suitable candidate may not be immediately available.
The short answer: a rejection at the offer stage is not always down to the offer itself. Three possible causes are differing expectations regarding salary and terms of employment, a late offer, and a competing proposal from another employer. These factors may also combine. You can sometimes pick up on signs of this earlier in the process; you just need to ask specific questions.
Why would a hard-to-find candidate still turn down the job after a successful interview?
A positive interview may suggest that the candidate finds the role and your organisation interesting, but this does not yet provide any certainty. You should therefore ask how they found the interview themselves. Even if they are enthusiastic, you still do not know whether your offer is the best option for them. A sought-after skilled worker or salesperson may be weighing up several options, even if they do not say so out loud.
Expectations were quietly diverging
The candidate had a salary figure in mind that was never specifically discussed. Or he was assuming a fixed day shift, whereas the role involves shift work. That discrepancy only comes to light once the offer is set out in writing. At that point, it feels like a disappointment for both parties.
The offer came too late
After the final interview, there may still be some internal coordination to take place: a signature from senior management, a second opinion from a colleague, or a contract being finalised by HR. To you, these are logical steps. To the candidate, however, it may feel like a silence. That silence can give rise to doubts in the candidate’s mind.
Another employer was quicker or more specific
Highly sought-after candidates are also approached by other employers. A quick and concrete offer can give you the edge. Sometimes the competition doesn’t win on salary, but on certainty: a concrete offer on the table versus a promise that ‘something will come along soon’.
What signs indicate an increased risk in the offer?
A rejection may be preceded by signs of hesitation. During the recruitment process, a candidate may already give an indication of where their reservations lie. Anyone who recognises such signs can discuss them before the offer is made.
Pay particular attention to these signs:
- Evasive answers about salary. ‘We’ll sort it out’ sounds positive, but says nothing about the amount the candidate is expecting.
- Questions about pace and decision-making. Does the candidate ask when they will receive a decision? This question may suggest that the candidate is also considering other options. You should therefore ask what their own plans are.
- React more slowly. If someone replied once on the same day and only now, a few days later, then something may have changed. It could also simply be down to them being busy. So do check to see how things stand.
- Doubts about practical matters. Journey time, working hours, overtime or a probationary period may seem like minor issues, but they can be the deciding factor.
- A current employer who makes a counter-offer. If the candidate says they ‘want to discuss it with their line manager first’, be prepared for a counter-offer.
Do you notice one or more of these signs? If so, ask a direct question: ‘What needs to be included in our proposal to make it a clear ’yes” for you?’ An honest answer before the proposal is made is more valuable than a polite “no” afterwards.
These signals are not separate from the rest of the route. In the main causes of drop-off in the candidate journey You can read about how dropouts occur in earlier stages.
What role do salary and terms of employment play?
Salary and terms and conditions can play a major role. Salary doesn’t have to be the only deciding factor, but an unexpected discrepancy can still derail an otherwise promising process. The solution isn’t necessarily to pay more. The key is to know, before making an offer, whether expectations are aligned.
Indeed points out that employers save time by discussing salary expectations at an early stage. This prevents you from proceeding with candidates whose desired salary exceeds your budget. An open discussion about remuneration builds trust and reduces the likelihood of surprises later on. That is exactly what the proposal stage is all about.
Look beyond the gross salary. Employers often think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group actually has different priorities. For one mechanic, a fixed day shift may be more important than a company car. For an experienced sales representative, security in the fixed portion of their pay or the freedom to organise their own schedule may be the deciding factor.
Would you like to know how your terms and conditions compare with the market? Then read What the data says about salaries and terms and conditions in the engineering sector and Which employment conditions do operators really consider important?. This way, you base your offering on what your target audience values, rather than on an assumption.
How can you prevent a competitor’s offer from beating you to it?
By planning ahead rather than waiting to see what happens. The Robert Half US website states that more than a third (35%) of the employers surveyed who missed out on a candidate in the past year, cited waiting too long to make an offer as the reason. That research does not specifically concern the Netherlands or hard-to-find profiles, but the principle is familiar: other employers are also competing for good candidates.
Here’s how to shorten the quotation phase without compromising on quality:
- Allocate the bandwidth internally straight away. Immediately after the final interview, agree on the limits within which you may offer a salary and terms of employment, before making a verbal or written offer. That way, you won’t need to seek approval again when making the offer.
- Ensure the decision-maker is available. Make sure that the person authorised to sign is available immediately after the final interview to approve and sign the offer, so that it does not remain unprocessed.
- Start by making a verbal offer. Call the candidate as soon as possible after you have made your decision. Discuss the proposal and ask for their reaction straight away.
- Please send the written offer as soon as possible. A proposal that takes days to materialise undermines the enthusiasm generated by the telephone conversation.
- Agree on a response time. A clear moment when you expect a decision prevents the process from stalling. Make sure the deadline is reasonable, so that the candidate does not feel under pressure.
You can find more ideas on how to speed up the whole process in Speeding up the recruitment process without compromising on quality.
What do you sort out in advance to avoid any surprises?
The offer should not contain any new information. Ideally, the candidate will already be familiar with everything it contains. You should therefore go through these points with the candidate one last time after the final selection interview and before the written offer is made. Use the overview below as a checklist for this final review.
| Subject | When to discuss | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Salary expectations and range | Immediately after the final interview, before you draw up the offer | A difference may then become apparent, rather than only when the written offer is made |
| Timetable, shifts and overtime | In the final consultation prior to the offer | Practical objections may lead to a rejection |
| Secondary conditions | In the final consultation prior to the offer | You check whether the aspects the candidate says are important to them are reflected in the offer |
| Other ongoing projects | After the final interview and when the offer is made verbally | You’ll get a better idea of how much time you might have |
| Timeline of the decision | Immediately after the final interview and upon receiving the offer | The candidate knows where they stand |
| Start date and notice period | Before the offer | Reduces the likelihood of last-minute discussions about the start |
Also explain why your organisation is a good fit for this role. A clear employer brand message gives the candidate reasons to choose you if they are torn between two offers. In Drawing up job descriptions for technical and blue-collar roles You’ll learn how to structure that story.
How does a guided process help during the proposal phase?
You can reduce the likelihood of a rejection by maintaining contact with the candidate right through to the end. At FosFor, our support covers everything from the campaign through to the application and follow-up. We handle the shortlisting and guidance, so that, on average, you as the client only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month.
Based on target audience data, we advise on what candidates within a specific target group consider important, such as terms of employment, communication and the application process. During the weekly strategic meeting, we discuss the results and next steps. This allows any concerns to be raised at an early stage. The decision on the job offer always remains with you. You can read more about our approach in our data-driven approach.
Have you recently lost a candidate at the final stage, or do you have an offer ready but are still unsure about it? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss together where the risks lie in your process.