Rejecting applicants without damaging your employer brand

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Rejection is part and parcel of recruitment. Yet for many candidates, it is precisely that moment that shapes the impression they form of your organisation. The short answer: reject candidates promptly, be personal, and provide honest, constructive feedback where possible. Do not leave anyone waiting in uncertainty. In a small or close-knit labour market, where professionals know one another, this carries extra weight. A mechanic or marine electrician who is turned down today could well be exactly the candidate you’re looking for a year from now.

This article deals with the situation where you, as an employer, reject a candidate. Has the candidate withdrawn their application? If so, read more about the main causes of drop-off in the candidate journey.

Why a quick, personal rejection carries more weight than you might think

Internally, a rejection often feels like the end of a case. For the candidate, it is an experience that sticks with them. Whether that experience is neutral, positive or negative depends very much on how you present it.

Research by CareerArc shows what happens when you fail to keep candidates informed. Candidates who hear nothing about the status or the decision regarding their application end up applying elsewhere 3.5 times less likely to reapply to the company that rejected them. The same survey shows that 72% of candidates who had a poor job application experience shared that experience: either online via a review site or social media, or directly with someone from their professional or personal network.

The latter is particularly relevant in a tight labour market. Think of a region with just a handful of shipyards, or a sector in which installers and operators know one another through colleagues and former employers. Word of a job application that never received a response spreads quickly in such environments. The CareerArc study does not say anything specific about Dutch regions or sectors, but the mechanism is familiar: experiences are shared, including with people who might apply for a job with you in the future.

Quick rejections: how to keep up the pace without coming across as rude

Speed is respect. The longer a candidate has to wait, the more they will start to fill in the blanks. Often, what they imagine is more negative than the reality. A clear ‘no’ is usually preferable to weeks of silence.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

Agree on a deadline in advance

In the application confirmation email, let the candidate know when they can expect to hear back. Agree on this timeframe internally with the hiring manager and stick to it. If that isn’t possible, send a brief update with a new date. This will prevent silence from being interpreted as a lack of interest.

Select the channel for each phase

Not every rejection requires a phone call. However, the following does apply: the more time a candidate has invested in your process, the more personalised the rejection should be.

Phase Appropriate channel What’s the minimum you’d say?
Following an initial screening of the CV or application form A personalised email or message The decision, the main reason in a single sentence, and thank you for your interest
After a brief telephone conversation An email or message, or perhaps a quick phone call The decision and a specific reason that ties in with the conversation
After one or more job interviews By telephone, with a brief confirmation by email The decision, specific feedback (if your organisation allows it) and, where applicable, the option to return at a later date

Are you phoning someone after a meeting? If so, make sure you’ve got your feedback ready in advance. A phone call with no substance can quickly feel like a mere formality.

Reject personally without using a generic standard message

A standard email saying ‘Unfortunately, we have chosen a candidate who is a better fit for the role’ comes across as an automated reply, because that is often what it is. A personalised message doesn’t have to be long. It’s just a matter of including a few details that show you’ve actually looked at the application.

  • Please state your name and position. Do not refer to the vacancy to which someone has applied as ‘the post’.
  • Refer to something specific. An experience from your CV or a topic discussed during the interview.
  • Briefly summarise the real reason. For example, a missing certificate, insufficient experience with a particular system, or a timetable that doesn’t work.
  • Show who made the decision. Sign with your name and a telephone number, not ‘HR Team’.

An example of a brief, personal rejection following an initial screening:

Hi (name), thank you for your application for the role of (job title). Your experience with (specific area) caught our attention. For this role, we’re looking for someone who can already carry out (required skill) independently, and we don’t yet see that reflected in your experience. For this reason, we won’t be taking your application any further. Do you have any questions? Please feel free to call me on (number).

Feel free to use a template as a starting point. The difference lies in the two or three lines that you adapt for each candidate.

Giving honest feedback in a friendly tone

Candidates want to know why it’s not going ahead. According to research by LinkedIn, 94%: candidates’ feedback following a job interview. LinkedIn does point out that some companies prohibit recruiters and hiring managers from providing specific feedback. So check first what has been agreed within your organisation.

Are you allowed to give feedback? If so, it helps to make it specific and relevant. LinkedIn mentions feedback on skills that still need developing, on how someone could handle a conversation better, or a suggestion to get more involved in the organisation.

How to give feedback that’s both honest and friendly

  1. Base your decision on pre-defined criteria. Feedback that can be traced back to a selection scorecard feels less like a personal judgement.
  2. Find out the reason from the decision-makers. As a recruiter, are you unsure why someone has been rejected? Check with the interviewers. A structured debriefing after the interview makes that easier.
  3. Describe behaviour and skills, not personality. ‘We lacked specific examples of fault analysis’ works better than ‘you didn’t come across as confident’.
  4. Choose one or two points. A long list sounds like a reckoning.
  5. End on a genuinely positive note. Only if it’s genuine. A forced compliment undermines the rest of your message.

Not selected for this vacancy, but I’m interested in the next one

Do you regularly look for the same types of roles, such as mechanics, operators or maritime professionals? If so, a rejected candidate isn’t necessarily the end of the story. Perhaps the timing wasn’t right, or they were missing a single skill that they’ve since acquired.

How you reject a candidate can influence whether they apply again later. LinkedIn reports that candidates four times more likely to consider a future opportunity with your company if you give them constructive feedback. The CareerArc study reveals the flip side: those who do not receive a reply are actually less likely to apply again.

In practical terms, this means:

Document your rejection process

A proper rejection should not depend on who happens to have time. With a few set rules, it becomes part of your process:

  • A fixed timeframe within which candidates are informed of the decision following each stage.
  • One owner per vacancy who sends rejection letters or makes phone calls.
  • Templates for each stage, with space for two or three personal lines.
  • An agreement on what you will and will not share as feedback.
  • A quick follow-up check: have all the candidates in this round received a response?

Would you like to know how candidates really perceive your employer brand, rather than how you see it yourselves? Then read what the data reveals about being an attractive employer.

At FosFor, follow-up and shortlisting form part of the recruitment process, and we advise on touchpoints throughout the candidate journey. Curious to find out how it works? Take a look at our data-driven approach or Discuss your application process with us.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.