Are you looking for a mechanic, welder or operator, but the vacancy remains unfilled? If so, you probably already have colleagues who know exactly the sort of skilled workers you’re after. With referral recruitment, you can turn those contacts into a permanent recruitment channel. It only works if your staff know exactly who you’re looking for, if it’s easy to make a recommendation, and if you follow up on every tip promptly. Think of it as a complement to your recruitment campaigns, not a replacement.
Below, you can read about how to set up referral recruitment for hard-to-fill blue-collar and technical roles. You’ll also learn about the risks involved in relying too heavily on this single channel.
Why does referral recruitment work for roles where there is a shortage of candidates?
When it comes to hard-to-find roles, you don’t want to rely solely on people who apply of their own accord. Referrals can also reach professionals who aren’t actively looking for jobs. Your own staff sometimes know such people personally: from a previous employer, from their studies, from a sports club or from the local area.
A recommendation from a colleague carries more weight than an advert. The candidate hears from someone they trust what the job is really like. You get a candidate who has already been through an initial screening, because your employee wouldn’t put their own reputation on the line without good reason.
Research supports this view, with one important caveat. A study using data from a single US company showed that Recommended candidates were hired more often and stayed with the company for longer. It concerned a single company in the United States, so you cannot apply that outcome directly to your organisation. It does, however, make it clear why many employers take this channel seriously.
There is another factor to consider when it comes to technical roles. Skilled professionals are well placed to judge whether someone is up to the job. An experienced electrician is better placed than a general job advert to know which former colleague has the right qualifications and the right work ethic.
What factors make a referral approach successful?
A referral programme stands or falls on its foundations. Many employers say in a team meeting that everyone “should ask around”, and then hear nothing more about it. This is rarely down to a lack of willingness. Usually, staff simply do not know exactly who they should put forward or what happens to their suggestion afterwards.
1. A clear description of the person you’re looking for
“We’re looking for technical staff” doesn’t get you very far. Give your staff a brief and specific job profile: which role, what experience or qualifications are really required, and what skills can a candidate still develop. The more precise the profile, the better the advice. A good initial interview with the hiring manager helps you clarify those requirements in advance.
2. A story that staff can pass on
Your colleagues should be able to explain why someone would want to work for you. Consider factors such as working hours, commute time, the type of projects and the atmosphere within the team. Employers often misjudge which benefits the target group considers important. Data regularly shows that professionals actually have different priorities to what employers assume. A EVP for technical and blue-collar roles provides staff with the right words.
3. Making recommendations should be easy
A long form or an email to HR that sits unanswered for days creates a barrier to action. Make sure there’s a single, simple route: a short link, a dedicated point of contact or a brief chat on the shop floor. Also give staff something to share, such as a job vacancy link or a short video. You can read about what kind of content is suitable for this in What sort of social recruitment content works for the tech sector?.
4. Prompt follow-up and feedback
Nothing slows down a referral scheme quite like a tip that is ignored. Call a recommended candidate within a few days and let the employee know how things are going – even if it isn’t a match. Anyone who feels, even once, that their tip has been filed away in a drawer won’t do it a second time.
5. Recognition that suits your team
Many employers opt to offer a reward upon a successful recruitment. This can help, but it is not the only thing that counts. Recognition from the line manager and visible results also make a big difference. If you opt for a financial reward, make sure you agree in advance when it will be paid out and coordinate the tax and administrative aspects with your payroll department.
Setting up a referral recruitment scheme in six steps
Once the terms and conditions are in place, you can start organising the programme in practical terms. Keep it small and straightforward; you can always expand it later.
- Select the functions. Start with the two or three vacancies that are the hardest to fill.
- Create a brief profile for each role. No more than half a page setting out the essential requirements, preferences and what makes the role attractive.
- Record the route. Who receives the tip, within how many days is contact made, and how does the employee receive feedback?
- Agree on the rules of the game. When does a referral count, what is the potential reward, and what happens if the same candidate is also referred through a campaign?
- Introduce the programme in person. Managers communicate this during staff meetings or on the shop floor, not just via an intranet message.
- Measure the result. Record the channel through which each applicant applied. This will show you what proportion of your hires come via referrals.
How do you combine referrals with a data-driven recruitment approach?
The number of candidates generated through referrals depends on the size and composition of your employees’ networks. The reach is limited to the people your team knows. To ensure a steady flow of candidates, you therefore also need channels that extend beyond your own network.
| Referrals via staff members | Paid recruitment campaigns | |
|---|---|---|
| Reach | Limited to your team’s network | Broad, to be tailored to role and region |
| Costs | Time for a follow-up, and perhaps a reward | Media budget, creative work and campaign management |
| Predictability | It varies, depending on who your colleagues know | Adjust based on campaign data |
| Strength | Trust and an honest picture of the work | Reaching potential candidates outside your own circle |
The two complement each other. You can use the insights from your target audience data – about what professionals value – both in your campaigns and in the story that staff pass on. And campaigns ensure that you also reach people whom nobody on your team knows. You can read about how to appeal to that group in reaching passive jobseekers.
Measure all channels in the same way. Don’t just look at the number of applications, but also at how many candidates make it through the selection process and stay on. You can read more about this in measuring the quality of your pool of applicants.
At FosFor, we combine target audience data, targeted campaigns and the initial shortlisting of candidates. On average, our clients interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month, and we discuss results and next steps in a weekly meeting. An in-house referral programme fits in perfectly with this. In our data-driven approach You can read about how the process works.
What are the risks associated with relying too heavily on a single channel?
If you rely mainly on referrals, you’ll end up recruiting from the same circles time and again, as employees put forward people from their own networks. That feels familiar, but it can limit the diversity of your candidate pool and narrow your pool of potential candidates.
A recent field experiment on gender segregation in occupations shows how this can play out. The researchers argue that referrals can reinforce the division between male- and female-dominated occupations. They studied 1,294 skilled workers across 12 occupations in the manufacturing and service sectors in Uganda. Candidates from the gender that was in the minority within a particular occupation were 23.4 percentage points less likely to be recommended, even when qualifications are equal. The networks of the employees surveyed also appeared to be segregated by gender. As this is a discussion paper based on data from a single country, you cannot apply these findings directly to your organisation. However, it does provide a reason to examine who is joining the workforce via referrals in technical professions where one group is significantly over-represented.
There are other pitfalls:
- We’re running out of network coverage. After the initial suggestions, things often go quiet, as staff have already mentioned their suitable contacts.
- Your selection will become less sharp. A recommended candidate must go through the same selection process as everyone else. Otherwise, you run the risk of hiring someone on the basis of friendship rather than suitability.
- Unpredictable intake. You can’t rely on people coming across the right contacts by chance. For predictable growth, you need channels that you can manage.
- Tension within the team. A rejected recommendation can be a sensitive matter. Clear criteria and proper feedback can prevent a lot of hassle.
The solution is not to stop using referrals, but to use them deliberately as one channel within a broader mix. Apply the same selection criteria to every candidate and regularly review the sources of your candidate intake.
Where are you starting tomorrow?
Choose one challenging vacancy, write a half-page profile and ask two managers to discuss it at their next team meeting. Agree on who will follow up on the suggestions within a few days. This way, you can quickly test whether your team has a useful network.
Have you noticed that referrals aren’t generating enough candidates for your hard-to-fill roles? If so, a broader approach is needed. Get in touch to discuss your hard-to-fill vacancy and how to combine referrals and recruitment campaigns.