Has your job advert been online for weeks and are you mainly receiving applications that aren’t quite right? Then you’ll want to know whether a recruitment campaign attracts higher-quality candidates than a job advert on a job board. The honest answer is that it depends on who you’re looking for.
Job boards mainly reach people who are currently actively looking for work. A targeted campaign can also reach people who aren’t actively looking, but who are open to something new. So, when it comes to recruitment marketing versus job sites, there isn’t always a clear winner. The right choice depends on the role, the availability of candidates in your target group and how quickly you need to fill the position.
Who do you reach through job sites?
A job board is a passive channel. You post the vacancy and wait for someone to search for a job, find your vacancy and apply. This means you mainly reach active candidates.
According to Indeed Job sites and job boards are a way of reaching active candidates quickly. Indeed also states that active candidates are a better fit for roles where you need to fill a vacancy quickly.
A job site therefore makes sense if:
- there are plenty of people actively looking for a job like yours;
- the job requirements are broad enough to attract a wider range of applications;
- you need to react quickly and don’t have time to set up a campaign first.
The downside is that your job vacancy is listed alongside those of other employers. Candidates will compare options, and you’re just one of them. If the role requires a rare skill set, it may also be the case that there are simply few people looking for work at that particular time.
If you choose this route, make sure your job vacancy is easy to find. In our article on Optimising your job advert for Google for Jobs You can read about how to go about it.
Who do you reach with a recruitment campaign?
A recruitment campaign works the other way round: you seek out the candidate rather than waiting for them to come to you. Indeed describes recruitment marketing as a recruitment strategy that uses marketing techniques to attract professionals with relevant skills. According to Indeed, this can also persuade passive jobseekers who need a little extra encouragement to change jobs.
Data-driven means that you determine in advance who you want to reach and what matters to that group. Employers often think that certain benefits are decisive, whilst data shows that the target group actually has different priorities. A target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies helps you identify those wishes.
Here, quality isn’t achieved through greater reach, but through a more targeted reach and a message that resonates with that group. A campaign does not automatically attract better candidates. A poorly targeted campaign is just as likely to attract unsuitable responses.
Would you like to know how to reach people who aren’t actively looking? Then read on how to reach passive jobseekers.
Active versus passive search behaviour: a side-by-side comparison
The main difference between the two approaches lies in the candidate’s search behaviour. An active candidate is looking for you. A passive candidate first needs to be persuaded to consider a move.
| Aspect | Job site | Recruitment campaign |
|---|---|---|
| Type of candidate | Actively searching, in particular | Not actively looking either, but open to something new |
| Initiative | The candidate is looking for you | You approach the target audience |
| Particularly suitable for | Roles for which you need to recruit someone quickly | Specialist or hard-to-fill roles |
| What the candidate needs | A clear, easy-to-find job vacancy | A good reason to think about switching |
| Point to note | Competition from other vacancies; in the event of a shortage, there may be few applications | Candidates aren’t actively looking for work, so keep the application process quick and straightforward |
That classification is in line with what Indeed states: passive candidates are better suited to specialist or senior roles. In a Another article mentions Indeed Passive recruitment is also a good strategy for senior roles or hard-to-fill positions.
Please bear in mind that a passive candidate is not actively looking for a job. You should therefore ensure that the application process is quick and straightforward, so that you can maintain their interest.
When do you combine both routes?
Often, a combination makes the most sense. Indeed states that both types of candidates can work well, depending on your needs, and that a sound recruitment plan incorporates a mix of strategies. Consider the following situations:
- Several vacancies with varying levels of demand. Post broader job descriptions on job sites and run a campaign for the roles you’re struggling to fill.
- Your vacancy has been open for a long time. If the job site doesn’t yield any suitable responses, you can also use a campaign to reach people who aren’t actively looking for work.
- You want to get started quickly. Post the job vacancy online straight away and set up the campaign alongside it.
- You want a steady flow of new students. A campaign raises your profile amongst your target audience, including for future job vacancies.
If you combine them, make sure both channels lead to the same clear application process. And measure the results for each source separately; otherwise, you won’t know afterwards what worked.
How do you assess whether a recruitment channel produces high-quality candidates?
The number of applications says little about quality. Greenhouse warns against relying on such superficial figures: a low conversion rate means little if the majority of applications are of poor quality. Greenhouse recommends focusing on metrics that you can improve yourself, such as:
- Source quality: Which source provides candidates who make it through the selection process and go on to become good employees?
- Progression per phase: Which proportion of the candidates will progress to the next stage of the selection process?
- Acceptance of offers: How many offers lead to an acceptance?
- Time to fill: How long does it take from the job advert being posted to the candidate being hired?
Compare job sites and recruitment campaigns side by side on these points. If one approach generates a lot of responses but few successful placements, you’ll know where you need to make adjustments. You can find more practical tips in our article on measuring the quality of your pool of applicants.
This is how FosFor approaches channel selection
FosFor combines recruitment, data and marketing. We analyse target audience data and public labour market data, draw on insights from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, and use these to set up targeted campaigns. We take care of the initial selection process.
On average, clients interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. Vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average, depending on the role and target group. Every week, we discuss the campaigns, results and next steps. The decision on who to hire remains yours. Read more about our data-driven approach.
Would you rather compare recruitment models than channels? If so, our article on Recruitment marketing versus a temporary employment agency better suited to your question.
Are you unsure which approach is best for your hard-to-fill vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your role, target audience and current results. We’ll then work out together whether a job site, a campaign or a combination of the two makes the most sense.