Has your vacancy for a team leader or shift supervisor been open for months? If so, you’re probably looking for someone who can master two things at once: the practical side of the job on the shop floor and managing people. That combination narrows down the pool of suitable candidates. Many of them aren’t actively looking for work either.
The short answer: recruiting team leaders for production and engineering works better if you stop recruiting in the same way as you would for an operator. You need a different message, a more specific profile and channels that reach people who are already leading informally but aren’t yet applying for jobs. Below, you can read why this profile is challenging and what steps you can take.
Why are team leaders and foremen harder to find than operators?
For an operator or technician, the main criteria are professional expertise, experience and availability. For a team leader, there is an additional layer to this. He or she must understand the technology or production process and be able to motivate, guide and hold a team to account.
Every additional requirement narrows down the pool. So you’re not searching the entire market for skilled workers, but only that section of the market which is both willing and able to take on a leadership role. That section is smaller than the pool of skilled workers who carry out the work.
There’s another factor at play. Those who know the profession well and are already managing a team often have a secure position, a good relationship with their team and little reason to leave. These candidates usually don’t see your vacancy on a job board, because they don’t look there.
Finally, even skilled professionals sometimes have their doubts. The step from colleague to manager feels like a big one. They wonder whether they’ll lose touch with their craft, whether they’ll soon find themselves working alongside former colleagues, and what the extra responsibility will entail. If your job advert doesn’t address those doubts, they’ll drop out before they even apply.
What combination of specialist knowledge and interpersonal skills are you looking for?
Many job vacancies for team leaders focus mainly on tasks: planning staff rota, monitoring production and liaising with the planning department. That’s true, but it says little about what makes someone successful in this role. So start by asking yourself what mix of qualities you really need.
Subject-specific
- Sufficient knowledge of machinery, plant or the production process to assess the significance of faults and deviations.
- An understanding of safety and quality, so that the team does not compromise on these when things get busy.
- The ability to step in when someone is absent, without the leadership role being lost.
Management
- Address colleagues about their behaviour and commitments, even if they used to be peers.
- Staying calm in the face of setbacks and making clear decisions at the start of a shift.
- Transmitting information between the office and the shop floor, in both directions.
- Inducting new colleagues and keeping experienced staff motivated.
Work with the hiring manager to decide which criteria are really important. A shift supervisor in a 24-hour production facility requires a different set of priorities to a team leader in an assembly department with day shifts. With the right questions to ask during the initial interview with the hiring manager Make sure you’ve finalised those decisions before the campaign starts.
How does your recruitment message differ from that aimed at operators or fitters?
For operational roles, the focus is often on the work itself, the rota and the terms and conditions. In the article on Which employment conditions do operators really consider important? You’ll find out how this works out for that target group. As a team leader, you build on this, but the focus shifts to influence, growth and support.
| Subject | Operator or fitter | Team leader or squad manager |
|---|---|---|
| The essence of the message | The work, the technology, the team | Responsibility for and influence over how the department operates |
| Doubts that you dispel | Timetable, journey time, workload | Whether the move is feasible and whether there is support for it |
| What you’re showing | Machinery, the workplace, colleagues | Freedom to make decisions and liaise with management |
| Terms and Conditions | Salary, allowances, job security | Differences in terms of job role, training and career progression |
Be specific about the support on offer. A professional taking on a formal leadership role for the first time will want to know whether there is a training programme, a coach or a regular sparring partner. Also be honest if the role involves some hands-on work on the shop floor. For many candidates, that actually makes the role more appealing.
Bear in mind the difference in remuneration. If the difference compared with the specialist role is small, candidates see little reason to take on the extra responsibility. If you’d like to know how to justify that difference, read what the data says about conditions in engineering.
Employers often think that certain benefits are the deciding factor, whilst data shows that the target audience has different preferences. You should therefore test your assumptions before you write the text, for example by a target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies.
Where can you find candidates who are already leading informally?
The best candidates are often the people who are already the point of contact for their team, without actually holding that title. They show new colleagues the ropes, step in when problems arise and are consulted by the team leader. You’ll find people like this in three places.
1. Within your own organisation
First, take a look at your own organisation. LinkedIn advises looking within the organisation for staff with the right aptitude, motivation and transferable skills, and investing in training so that they can fill any gaps (LinkedIn Talent Blog). For a team leader role, this means: ask your current managers who is already taking on that role informally.
2. In your existing candidate database
Have you spoken to candidates before who just missed out on being selected? LinkedIn suggests using your existing candidate database as a source, with a focus on ‘Silver Medalists’ and candidates with whom you already have a relationship (LinkedIn Talent Blog). A strong operator whom you previously turned down may now be ready for more.
3. Through your staff’s network
According to the same LinkedIn source, a referral scheme helps to identify candidates who are already connected to your team members, making them more likely to respond. Your professionals often know exactly who’s calling the shots at another employer.
Beyond your network: reach those who aren’t looking
If you’re working outside your own network, you’ll need channels that reach people who aren’t actively looking. Consider targeted campaigns on social media or professional networks, depending on where your target audience is. Which channel works best varies depending on the role and region. You can read more about this approach in reaching passive jobseekers.
How FosFor helps with the recruitment of front-line managers
FosFor combines recruitment, data and marketing, and focuses on blue-collar roles in sectors such as engineering, industry and manufacturing. When filling a team leader vacancy, the process begins by asking what this target group really values, so that your message addresses their concerns and aspirations.
This is followed by targeted campaigns and the initial selection process. On average, you’ll only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month, as FosFor handles the pre-selection and guidance. Vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average, depending on the role and target group. The decision on who to hire remains yours.
Every week, you discuss the campaigns, results and next steps together. This allows you to make adjustments if it turns out that the message or channel isn’t resonating. Read more about our data-driven approach or view results achieved by top-performing organisations.
Are you looking for a team leader or shift supervisor, but you’re not getting any responses to your job vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your vacancy. Then we’ll work out together where the process is currently getting stuck.