Developing a recruitment strategy: from data to campaign plan

6 mins’ read time

Tadaah team meeting

Has your vacancy been open for months, even though you’re advertising it? If so, the problem often lies not in the amount of effort you’re putting in, but in the decisions behind it. What message, for whom, via which channel? For many employers, these decisions are based on gut feeling or on what worked last time.

Developing a data-driven recruitment strategy revolves around four questions:

  • What is the job market like for this role?
  • Who is your target audience, and what do they consider important?
  • How do you stand out from other employers who are looking for the same sort of people?
  • What message and channels follow from this?

Only once you have answered those questions should you draw up a campaign plan. Data does not remove every uncertainty. However, it does make your decisions measurable, so that you can use the results to determine what adjustments you need to make.

Would you like to get a clear picture of how strategy and campaigns relate to one another first? Then read the difference between recruitment marketing and recruitment strategy. This article is about the building process itself.

What data do you use as the basis for your recruitment strategy?

A robust strategy is based on multiple types of data. A single source gives you part of the picture, but never the whole story. These four sources complement one another.

Public labour market data

This shows you just how tight the market is for your role, in your region and sector. The Labour Market Information and Advice Department of The UWV provides an overview of national, regional and sectoral developments. To this end, the UWV uses its own data, such as unemployment benefits and job vacancies, supplemented by external sources. Using the dashboards, you can view information by topic, edit tables and download figures.

You can find more freely available resources in our overview of labour market data that you can use without expensive tools.

Target audience data

Labour market figures show how many people there are. Target group data reveals what motivates those people. Think of terms and conditions of employment, fringe benefits, communication styles and how the application process works. You can read about how to approach this for operational roles in carry out a target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies.

Competition data

Which employers are fishing in the same pond, and what are they promising? Without that picture, you won’t know whether your message stands out or gets lost amongst ten similar job vacancies.

Your own recruitment data

Take a look back at previous vacancies. Where did the good candidates come from? At what stage did they drop out? How long did it take from application to the first interview? Those figures reveal where your process is falling short, even if you’ve never consciously collected them.

Step-by-step guide: how to turn labour market data into a campaign plan

Once the data is on the table, the real work begins: making decisions. The step-by-step guide below works for a single challenging vacancy, but also for a recurring recruitment need.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

Step 1: Make the recruitment question specific

Set out exactly which role you’re looking to fill, how many people you’re recruiting, which requirements are absolute musts, and when the successful candidate needs to start. A vague job description leads to a vague recruitment campaign. The clearer you are in distinguishing between absolute musts and preferences, the less likely you are to unnecessarily exclude suitable candidates.

Step 2: analyse the labour market

Find out how competitive the market is for this role in your region and sector. If the pool of candidates is small, you’ll probably need to reach out to people who aren’t actively looking. That requires a different approach to simply posting a job advert and waiting to see what happens.

Step 3: Test your assumptions against target audience data

This is where things often go wrong. Employers think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target audience actually has different priorities. So, start by writing down what you think attracts candidates. Then compare that with what the target audience itself says. The differences are your most important input for the message.

Step 4: analyse competing employers

Competitor analysis determines how you position yourself. LinkedIn recommends that you to research competitors’ careers websites and social media pages, so that your message and content stand out. If your story sounds too much like that of other employers, you’re less likely to catch a candidate’s attention.

So don’t just look at the salary. Also pay attention to the tone, the visuals, the promises everyone makes and the topics nobody mentions. You’ll find a practical guide in Labour market competition analysis: how to stand out.

Step 5: translate insights into a message and channel

Now you link each insight to a specific decision. LinkedIn suggests creating candidate personas as a useful tool: if you know what motivates ideal candidates and which platforms they are likely to visit, you can tailor your content to them. The table below shows how this might work in practice. These are examples, not set rules.

Insights from data Choice of message Choice of channel or approach
The target group is small and hardly ever searches actively Show straight away what the job has to offer, without a long company introduction Channels where you can reach people who don’t look at job sites
Candidates value working hours more than a company car Put your timetable and free time at the top Test several versions of the message and compare the responses
Competitors all promise the same thing Explain what you do differently and give reasons for it Use your own images and staff rather than stock photos
Candidates drop out during the recruitment process Explain in the job advertisement how the process works A streamlined application process and prompt follow-up

Choose the channel based on where your target audience is and how they go about making decisions. There is no single channel that works best for every purpose.

Step 6: finalise the campaign plan and make any necessary adjustments

Put everything on a single page: target audience, key message, channels, schedule, who will follow up on responses and by when. Agree in advance which metrics you will track and when you will discuss them. You can read about which metrics are useful for this in Measuring recruitment campaign figures. A strategy is only complete if you have the courage to adapt it based on results.

When is an external strategy session a good idea?

You can work through this step-by-step guide yourself. However, you may sometimes get stuck. External help is particularly useful if:

  • your vacancy has been open for a long time, even after several recruitment campaigns;
  • you get lots of responses, but few suitable candidates;
  • you do not have the time or capacity to collect and analyse data;
  • you are recruiting for a new target group, role or region;
  • You have internal doubts as to whether your own perception of the target audience is accurate.

FosFor develops recruitment strategies based on data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, public labour market data, target audience research and competitor analyses. Our approach combines data-driven strategy and the TEAM framework with targeted campaigns and the initial screening of candidates. Every week, we review campaigns, results and next steps.

The decision on who to hire is entirely up to you. On average, you’ll only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month, as we take care of the pre-selection and guidance. Vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average, depending on the role and target group. You can read more about our approach at our data-driven approach.

Your first step towards a data-driven strategy

Start small. Pick your most challenging vacancy and write down why you think candidates would choose you. Next, look up the labour market figures for that role and examine three competing job vacancies. By comparing this information, you’ll see where your assumptions might differ from what the labour market and competing vacancies show.

Would you like to work together on a difficult-to-fill vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting, then we’ll look at what data you need and what a suitable campaign plan might look like.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.