Comparing recruitment channels: which channel is right for your role?

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

No single recruitment channel works best for every hard-to-fill role. Which channel is right depends on three questions. Where is your target audience? Are they actively looking for work or not? And what sort of content will convince them?

For many blue-collar roles, a social media platform such as Meta or TikTok may be a sensible way to reach people who aren’t actively looking for work. LinkedIn is more often suited to commercial roles and profiles where work experience and career progression are key. Google for Jobs mainly reaches people who are already looking for work.

You can determine which mix is best suited to your vacancy by looking at target audience data, rather than based on a fixed preference. Below, we compare the four channels with one another. Details on how to set up each channel technically can be found in the separate articles to which we refer throughout.

Comparing recruitment channels: what should you look out for?

Anyone comparing recruitment channels often starts with reach: where are the most people? For hard-to-fill roles, that’s the wrong question to ask first. What matters is where your specific target audience is, what their mindset is there, and what you can show them.

Channel The candidate’s search behaviour How to reach people Content that suits
Meta (Facebook, Instagram) Mainly passive: scrolling, not searching Based on interests and behaviour on the platform A short video, photos of the workplace, a clear hook
LinkedIn Passive, but in a work and career context Through the network’s professional context Text detailing the role, development and impact
Google for Jobs Active: the candidate is looking for a job themselves By searching for a job title or role A comprehensive, clear job advertisement
TikTok Passive: watching for entertainment Based on interests Authentic footage of the workplace and colleagues

When it comes to hard-to-find roles, there’s a good chance that skilled professionals already have a job. They don’t look at job sites, but they can be persuaded if the right opportunity comes along. That’s why passive recruitment channels are so often used for hard-to-fill vacancies. You can read more about this group in our article on reaching passive jobseekers.

When is Meta a better option than LinkedIn for a job vacancy?

Meta often works better when your target audience has little reason to set up a professional network, but does use Facebook or Instagram on a daily basis. Think of operators, fitters, warehouse staff or tradespeople in the construction industry. If your target audience data shows that your candidates are mainly active on LinkedIn, then the choice is the other way round.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

The difference lies in how you find people. Meta itself explains that it uses information that people share, as well as the posts, pages and articles they click on or ‘like’, to to determine which adverts might be relevant. So you reach people based on their interests, not on an active search query.

Please bear in mind that there is a restriction. Meta states that advertisers based in or targeting the US, Canada and certain European countries does not allow job adverts to be targeted by age, gender or postcode. You should therefore check your ad settings to see which targeting options are available for your campaign. Above all, build your campaign around strong content that appeals to your target audience, rather than relying on demographic filters.

When LinkedIn is the better choice

LinkedIn gains ground as soon as work experience, career history and the nature of the role carry more weight than the image of the workplace. Think of account managers, internal sales roles or technical positions where candidates actively track their own development. For this target group, a message focusing on substance often works better than a short video.

Are you unsure which one to choose? Then test them side by side using the same message. You can read about how to set up each channel in Advertise a job vacancy on Facebook and Instagram for engineering roles and Setting up a LinkedIn recruitment campaign for engineering roles.

For which roles is Google for Jobs a natural addition?

Google for Jobs is a useful addition for roles where candidates search specifically by job title and location. Examples include drivers, forklift operators, warehouse staff and mechanics. Jobseekers simply type in a search query and want to see a clear job vacancy straight away.

It is rarely the only channel for a hard-to-find role. The best candidates are often not actively looking. Nevertheless, it complements social media campaigns well: someone who has seen an advert on Instagram may start searching for themselves later on. If your job vacancy is easy to find, you won’t lose that candidate along the way.

A prerequisite is a comprehensive job advertisement with clear terms and conditions. You can find out how to go about this in Optimising your job advert for Google for Jobs. For transport, see Recruiting drivers through Google campaigns how search behaviour shapes the approach.

In what way does TikTok offer something extra compared to the other platforms?

TikTok can be a useful addition if you have footage that appeals to your target audience and your workplace has something to show. It works best as an additional channel alongside Meta or Google, not as a replacement. Without useful videos from the workplace, it’s of little use.

This channel is of interest for entry-level roles, career changers and roles where the work itself is appealing to watch, such as welding, installation work or working on a shipyard. A short video of a colleague explaining what they do often says more than a list of requirements.

Do you want to reach young people, for example to offer them a work-study placement? TikTok reports that Targeting settings may not be available for audiences under the age of 18. Please bear this in mind beforehand. You can read about the opportunities and pitfalls in TikTok recruitment for blue-collar workers.

Decision aid: which channel is best suited to which role?

The table below is a starting point for testing, not a fixed rule. Two employers offering the same role may have different target groups, for example due to region, shift patterns or level of experience.

Job type Logical start channel Possible addition Please note
Production and operators Meta Google for Jobs Show timetables and conditions that the target audience considers important
Installation and maintenance Meta TikTok, Google for Jobs Images of real projects are more convincing than stock photos
Logistics and drivers Google for Jobs Meta Active jobseekers expect a prompt response
Maritime professionals Meta LinkedIn for experienced engineers People changing careers need a different message to experienced professionals
Sales and account management LinkedIn Meta The nature of the role and career progression are often key factors

How to determine your channel mix based on target audience data

The right mix of channels is determined by what you know about your target audience, not by what you’re used to. Employers often think they know what matters to their target audience, whilst the data regularly tells a different story. This applies to terms and conditions of employment, and just as much to communication channels.

  1. Describe your target audience. Who are you looking for, what are they doing at the moment, and what matters to them? To find this out, use a target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies.
  2. Determine search behaviour. Is your target audience actively searching, or do you need to attract them? That determines the balance between search and social channels.
  3. See what sort of content you can create. If you don’t have any footage, a video channel won’t be of any use until you’ve sorted that out first.
  4. Start with two channels. This way, you can compare options without spreading your budget too thinly.
  5. Measure by quality, not by clicks. Count how many suitable candidates each channel produces. Find out how in Measuring recruitment campaign figures.
  6. Adjust your approach based on what the data shows. TikTok gives an example: if a lot of conversions come from an interest you hadn’t selected, then it may help you add that interest to your targeting. You can also use these insights to adjust the distribution across channels.

How we go about this

At FosFor, we base our choice of channels on target audience data, public labour market data and data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns. Every week, we’ll discuss the campaigns, the results and the next steps with you. This way, you can redirect your budget towards what works, rather than sticking with a channel that only generates clicks.

We take care of the shortlisting. On average, clients only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates each month. The decision on who to hire remains yours. You can read more about this in our data-driven approach.

Are you unsure which channel is best suited to your hard-to-fill vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss your role and target audience. Then, together, we’ll look at where your candidates are and which mix is worth testing.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.