Twenty CVs in your inbox feel like progress. But if, after three interviews, you still haven’t found anyone suitable, you’ve mainly wasted your time. Do you want to choose a recruitment agency that provides high-quality candidates? Then don’t judge the agency on the number of responses it generates. Look at three things: how the agency selects candidates, how transparently it reports, and how well it understands your target audience.
You can assess these points as early as the first meeting. A fee or type of contract says little about the quality of the shortlist. Would you like to compare models and costs? Then read our article on Compare recruitment agency fees: commission or fixed fee. This article discusses the following: how can you tell if a recruitment agency is providing you with the right candidates?
Why more job applications do not necessarily mean better candidates
Many agencies report on things that are easy to quantify: the number of applications, processing time and cost per response. These figures are useful, but they don’t tell you whether the candidate will still be happy working for you six months down the line.
In an article by SHRM on measuring the quality of hire A recruitment expert cites ‘time-to-fill’ and ‘cost-per-hire’ as metrics for the speed and cost of the recruitment process. They are relevant, but, in his view, they do not show the impact a new hire has on business objectives. He cites staff turnover, performance appraisals and the hiring manager’s satisfaction as useful approaches, provided you are aware of their limitations. They are not measures of quality in their own right.
For you, this means: don’t just ask an agency how many candidates it provides. Also ask how the agency monitors whether those candidates are a good fit and stay on.
What questions should you ask a recruitment agency about selection criteria?
The quality of a shortlist depends on the criteria the agency uses. If these are clear from the outset, you can assess later why a particular candidate was or wasn’t shortlisted. If they are vague, you end up with candidates chosen on the basis of gut feeling.
Five questions for your first interview
- What criteria will you and I agree on before the recruitment process begins? A good agency probes further into specific requirements, preferences and the situations in which a person is expected to perform.
- How do you assess candidates during the initial selection process? Ask whether every candidate is asked the same questions and whether answers are marked against set criteria.
- Who decides whether to proceed, and on what basis? You want to know which decisions the agency makes and which ones are left to you.
- What happens to candidates who just fall short of the requirements? The answer shows whether the agency deliberately weighs up the options or simply filters them.
- Could you explain, for each candidate, why they are a good fit? A detailed assessment of each candidate is more valuable than a pile of CVs.
That second question deserves special attention. The US Office of Personnel Management states that more structured interviews demonstrate greater validity, reliability and inter-rater agreement, as well as fewer adverse effects. In a highly structured interview, all candidates are asked the same pre-determined questions and follow-up questions, which are scored according to fixed criteria. If an agency operates in this way, you can monitor and verify its decisions.
How to tell the difference between volume and quality
In practice, you often start to see the difference after just the first few weeks. This comparison will help you assess an agency’s work.
| Signal | Focused on volume | Focused on quality |
|---|---|---|
| Submission | Lots of CVs, little explanation | A few candidates, with reasons given for each one |
| Conversations | You’ll do the first round of selection yourself | You’ll mainly be speaking to candidates who have already been shortlisted |
| Rejections | Many candidates are eliminated on the basis of the basic requirements | Rejections are about nuances, not basic requirements |
| Reporting | Number of comments and clicks | Progression by stage and reasons for dropout |
| After the start | The desk is out of shot | The agency wants to know how the new employee is getting on |
A useful check: keep track of how many of the candidates put forward you wish to interview further after the first interview. If this is only a small proportion, it may indicate a mismatch in the pre-selection process. Also check whether the selection criteria, expectations and the assessment of the interview are consistent with one another. You can find more practical guidelines in our article on measuring the quality of your pool of applicants.
What role do feedback and transparency play?
A shortlist improves the more the agency takes your opinion on board. This only works if there is a regular flow of feedback, in both directions.
Look out for these signs:
- After each interview, the agency asks why a candidate was or was not suitable and adjusts the criteria accordingly.
- You’ll gain an insight into where candidates drop out: at the job advert stage, the application stage, the initial contact or the job offer.
- There is a regular meeting at which the campaign, results and next steps are discussed together.
- The agency isn’t afraid to tell you when your offer or recruitment process is costing you candidates.
That last point is perhaps the most distinctive. An agency that simply delivers what you ask for won’t tell you that your recruitment process is taking too long or that your terms and conditions are lagging behind. Do you want to organise such a consultation effectively yourself? Then take a look at our Agenda for a weekly recruitment meeting.
How can you tell if an agency really understands its target audience?
An agency that understands your target audience doesn’t talk about “candidates” in general terms. It knows what a mechanic, operator or account manager looks for, how they go about their search, and what puts them off.
The Office of Personnel Management describes, for posts that are difficult to fill, a recruitment plan by target group. That plan is drawn up in collaboration with subject-matter experts from the organisation to determine how to reach specific groups. That collaboration with people who know the field is also a good yardstick for an agency.
Questions that reveal knowledge of the target audience
- What does this target group consider important in a new job, and what are you basing that on?
- Which conditions or benefits do employers often overestimate?
- What do this group’s interests lie in, even when they aren’t actively looking?
- Which employers am I competing with for the same people?
Listen to the reasoning behind it. “That always works” is an assumption. An answer that refers to target audience research, labour market data or previous campaigns is an insight. Read on to find out how you can carry out a target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies, so that you can better assess the responses from an agency.
How FosFor applies these criteria
At FosFor, we work with data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, target audience data and public labour market data. This often reveals that employers believe certain benefits are important, whilst the target audience actually has different preferences. We use these insights to shape the job offer, the message and the selection process.
We take care of the shortlisting and support. On average, clients only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates each month. The final decision remains yours. Every week, we discuss campaigns, results and next steps, so you can see what’s happening and why. You can read about how this works, step by step, at our data-driven approach. You can find examples by sector at the results achieved by top-performing organisations.
Are you mainly unsure about the different recruitment models? If so, our article on recruiting staff through recruitment marketing or an employment agency.
Is there a hard-to-fill vacancy and would you like to know how to apply those quality criteria in your situation? Arrange an introductory meeting. We’ll then look together at your role, your target audience and your current shortlist.