Candidate journey analysis: where do candidates really drop out?

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Has your vacancy been open for weeks and are you receiving too few suitable applications? In that case, the first instinct is often to increase the budget, try a different channel or rewrite the job advertisement. Without analysing the candidate journey, you’re simply guessing at the cause.

The short answer: measure each touchpoint as a separate step and identify where the gap between incoming traffic and conversion is greatest. Are few people in your target audience seeing your job advert? If so, the problem often lies with the campaign. Are you getting lots of visitors but few applications? Then take a look at the job advert or the application form. Are you receiving enough applications, but few of them lead to good interviews? In that case, you should first examine the follow-up and selection process, but also check whether the campaign and job advertisement are generating the right expectations and attracting the right candidates.

Below you will find a diagnostic method that links the individual steps together. If you are primarily looking for the individual causes of failure, please read this first the main causes of drop-off in the candidate journey. This article looks at where things go wrong in your process.

What touchpoints form part of the candidate journey?

The candidate journey is the path a candidate takes from the moment they first see your job vacancy until the moment they accept your offer. To analyse this, you divide the journey into four stages. These stages correspond to the four points where things usually go wrong.

Zone Points of contact What you measure
1. Campaign Advertisement, social media post, job site Impressions within your target audience, clicks
2. Job advertisement and application Careers page, application form Visitors, applications started and completed
3. Follow-up Confirmation of receipt, first phone call, arranging an appointment Response time, availability, cancellations
4. Selection Pre-screening, interview, job offer Progress per round, reasons for rejection, accepted offers

Each zone has its own inflow and outflow. If you only look at the end result – for example, a shortage of suitable candidates – you won’t be able to identify which zone the leak is in. And so you might adjust the campaign, when in fact the problem only begins after the application stage.

How do you distinguish between a reach issue and a conversion issue?

If you’re having an audience reach issue, the right people won’t see your job advert. If you’re having a conversion issue, they’ll see it but won’t apply. These two problems require completely different solutions. Increasing your budget can help if your current budget is limiting your reach. If the issue lies with your targeting, region or profile selection, you should adjust those settings first. In the case of a conversion problem, increasing your budget won’t solve the root cause, as you’ll simply be directing more people to a job advert that isn’t convincing enough.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

For campaigns aimed at brand awareness and reach, Google recommends tracking metrics such as impressions and conversions, and reaching as many people within the target audience as possible (Google Ads Help). Applied to advertising: if you suspect a reach issue, first check whether your target audience is actually seeing your advert before you start tweaking the copy.

Signs of a range problem

  • Your advert is receiving few impressions amongst your target audience.
  • Your reach is extensive, but it falls outside the relevant region or profile.
  • The applications we are receiving are fundamentally unsuitable for the role.

Signs of a conversion problem

Here, you’re looking at the conversion rate. Google calculates the conversion rate by dividing the number of conversions by the number of ad interactions that can be attributed to a conversion during the same period. With 50 conversions out of 1,000 interactions, that works out at 5% (Google Ads Help). In recruitment, for example, you could use a completed job application as a conversion.

  • Lots of clicks, few applications submitted: This may indicate that the job advertisement or the offer is not compelling. You should also check whether the clicks are coming from your target audience, whether the ‘Apply’ button is easy to find, and whether the page is functioning correctly from a technical point of view.
  • Many job applications started, few completed: This may indicate that the form is too long, difficult to complete or technically flawed. Mandatory documents or exclusionary questions may also be a factor. Check each field to see where candidates drop out and test the form on a mobile phone.
  • Visitors leave straight away: This may indicate that the job vacancy page does not match what the advert promises. You should also check that the page loads properly and that the advert is reaching the right people.

A conversion problem is often a content problem. Employers frequently believe that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target audience actually has different preferences. If you’d like to know which campaign metrics to track for this, read What the data from your recruitment campaign reveals.

What signs indicate a succession problem rather than a selection problem?

As soon as an application is received, anything that goes wrong afterwards tends to look like a recruitment issue. Yet the problem often lies earlier: in the period between the application and the first point of contact. Anyone who doesn’t hear anything during that time may already be in talks with another employer.

Indeed cites the measurement of KPIs such as response times, email open rates and candidate satisfaction scores as a way of identifying bottlenecks and sources of frustration in your process (Indeed). These figures help you to distinguish between follow-up and selection.

It suggests succession rather than

  • candidates can no longer be contacted during the initial telephone call;
  • people cancel before the meeting takes place;
  • candidates indicate that they are now in discussions with other organisations;
  • There are a few days between applying for a job and the first contact.

It suggests selection rather than

  • candidates do attend interviews, but are consistently rejected on the same grounds;
  • hiring managers reject many candidates without clear, pre-agreed criteria;
  • different assessors may assess the same candidate very differently.

A useful rule of thumb: if candidates withdraw themselves, take a look at your succession planning. If you reject them, review your selection criteria or the recruitment process that leads to those candidates. If your offer is turned down after a good interview, check the terms and conditions of employment and how you explained them during the interview. To find out how to make decisions more quickly without compromising on quality, read Speeding up the recruitment process without compromising on quality.

How to make a diagnosis in five steps

Using the four zones and the indicators above, you can carry out an initial assessment yourself. Do this on a job-by-job basis, as a technical role is different from a sales role.

  1. Document the journey. Make a note of all points of contact, from the advert to the offer, and note down who is responsible for each step.
  2. Measure the inflow and outflow for each zone. Always use the same time period so that you can compare the figures.
  3. Find the biggest fall. Compare it with previous job vacancies or with similar roles within your own organisation. What are the main differences compared with what you’re used to?
  4. Look beyond the figures. Walk through your recruitment process yourself, read the job advert from the perspective of your target audience, and ask candidates who dropped out why they did so.
  5. Change one thing at a time and measure again. If you adjust your text, channel and process all at once, you won’t know afterwards what made the difference.

Are you unsure which of the two zones to choose? Then start with the earliest one. A leak at the top of the funnel affects everything that comes after it, so fixing it first makes the subsequent figures more reliable.

When is an external analysis more helpful than internal figures?

Internal figures show what is happening, but not always why. An external candidate journey analysis is particularly useful in the following situations:

  • There are gaps in your data – for example, because you can’t see who clicks through from an advert to a form, or because follow-up emails are scattered across different inboxes.
  • There are too few vacancies per role to identify any patterns.
  • You’ve already tried several adjustments without any noticeable difference.
  • You’re not sure whether your assumptions about what your target audience considers important are correct.

As part of Candidate Journey Optimisation, FosFor analyses the application process and touchpoints, with the aim of engaging candidates more quickly and reducing drop-out rates. We compare this analysis with data from hundreds of recruitment campaigns, target audience data and public labour market data. This allows you to see not only where candidates drop out, but also what the target group expects at that stage.

If you also outsource the implementation, we’ll support you from the campaign stage right through to the interview and follow-up, with weekly strategic meetings to discuss results and next steps. We’ll take care of the shortlisting: on average, you’ll only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. The decision on who to hire remains yours. You can read about how this works in practice in our data-driven approach.

Would you like to know at which stage your candidates are dropping out? Bring your most recent hard-to-fill vacancy and the figures you already have to the meeting. Then we’ll look together at where you should start your search. Arrange an introductory meeting.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.