Candidate experience survey: what job applicants tell you

6 mins’ read time

Tadaah team meeting

Your funnel data shows where candidates drop out. What it doesn’t show is why. A candidate experience survey fills that gap. You ask applicants themselves how they experienced your process: from applying to the interview and the communication surrounding it. This reveals areas for improvement that aren’t reflected in the figures, such as unclear expectations, an interview that failed to engage the candidate, or a next step that felt slow.

The short answer: candidate feedback does not replace your data, but it does make that data interpretable. Combine the two, ask brief and anonymous questions, and translate the answers directly into one specific change at a time.

What does the data show, and what do candidates themselves say?

Internal figures are very effective at highlighting a problem. For example, you might notice that many people stop responding after the initial assessment, or that offers are frequently turned down. In measuring the quality of your pool of applicants It’s a question of ratios like these for each step.

But a ratio is an indicator, not an explanation. A low offer-to-accept rate may be down to terms of employment, speed, unrealistic expectations or a competitor who acted more quickly. You cannot determine which of these factors applies in your case simply by looking at the figure.

That’s where immediate feedback helps. Candidates describe how something felt: whether they knew what the next step was, whether they were able to ask their questions about working hours or travelling time, or whether the form was a hassle. The HR organisation SHRM advises that to analyse feedback from candidate surveys alongside your recruitment figures, precisely in order to gain a proper understanding of the candidate experience. Isolated answers without figures amount to anecdotes; figures without answers amount to guesswork.

Would you like to get your internal affairs in order first? Then read on to find out which Causes of drop-off in the candidate journey you can recognise yourself in this process. This article looks at the other side of the coin: what the candidate themselves says.

Which questions provide useful feedback without causing delays?

Keep it brief. A candidate who has just had an interview or been turned down won’t bother filling in a long questionnaire. Three to five questions that can be answered in a couple of minutes work better in practice than a lengthy survey that nobody finishes. That’s advice, not a fixed rule: test for yourself what works best for your response rate.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

SHRM identifies three areas where questions in a candidate questionnaire should focus on: how easy or difficult the application process was, how the candidate found the interviews, and how well the recruiter or hiring manager communicated. This ties in well with the aspects of your own process that you can influence.

A compact layout might look like this:

  • How to apply: How easy was it to apply for the job? (on a scale of 1–5)
  • Conversation: Were you able to ask the questions that were important to you during the interview, for example about the rota, travelling time or the team? (yes / partly / no)
  • Communication: Did you know, after each point of contact, what the next step was and when it would take place? (yes / partly / no)
  • Open question: What would be the first thing you’d change about this recruitment process?

That final open-ended question is often the most valuable. A scaling question tells you that something isn’t quite right; the open-ended question tells you what it is. Use the language of your target audience. A mechanic or operator doesn’t want to read HR jargon, but rather a question that sounds like a normal conversation.

How do you get honest answers?

Honesty depends on how safe it feels to offer criticism. A candidate who is still in the running is more likely to say something nice. SHRM highlights precisely this tension: candidates who think they are still in the running for the job tend to say positive things more often rather than rejected candidates. According to the same article, you should promise anonymity and make it clear that the survey is unrelated to the vacancy. Having an external party conduct the survey is even better, according to the expert interviewed.

You see the same principle outside the recruitment sector. In a 2021 UK onboarding survey of new police officers, participants were asked complete anonymity, with the aim of eliciting more responses and honest feedback. The report describes this as the intention; it is not proof that anonymity always yields more honest answers. However, it provides a logical basis for your own approach.

Interviewing successful candidates

New staff members have been through the whole process and are therefore best placed to tell you about it. At the same time, they have a vested interest: they want to get off to a good start. So don’t ask them during their first meeting with their line manager, but via a short, anonymous questionnaire. Also ask what ultimately convinced them to join and what almost made them decide against it.

Conducting follow-up interviews with unsuccessful candidates

Rejected candidates are often more critical, and that is exactly what you’re looking for. Only send the questionnaire after a clear, personalised rejection. Make it clear that the answers will not affect future applications. Expect a lower response rate, and do not give the answers any more or less weight than those of successful candidates: you need both perspectives.

Be mindful of privacy. Record what data you store and for how long. In how long you are allowed to keep job application details under the GDPR You can read about what you need to bear in mind.

How do you turn feedback into concrete improvements?

Gathering feedback is the easy part. It’s often when it comes to acting on it that things get stuck. An example of how it can be done: the US Office of Personnel Management analysed search data and user feedback from the USAJOBS job portal and then consolidated all the search filters into a single tab, as this had been a frequently cited pain point in user research. The data and feedback together led to a single, concrete change.

This step-by-step guide will help you with your own process:

  1. Link answers to a process step. Group comments by stage: job vacancy, application form, initial contact, interview, job offer.
  2. Put them next to your marks. Do you notice any dropouts at the same stage? If so, that’s a strong indication of where you should start.
  3. Choose one area for improvement. For example: confirm the next step within an agreed timeframe after each conversation.
  4. Appoint an owner. Who makes the adjustments, and when do you review them?
  5. Take the measurement again. Do the feedback and the mark change at that stage? If so, you’re on the right track. If not, look for another cause.

Discuss the results at a set time, for example during your recruitment meeting. This way, feedback becomes a regular part of your approach, rather than a one-off project. If you then want to speed up your process, take a look at Speeding up the recruitment process without compromising on quality.

What should you look out for when reading the results?

A few pitfalls to bear in mind:

  • Small numbers. With just a handful of responses, a single prominent candidate does not constitute a trend. See if anything else comes up more frequently.
  • A biased response. People who are very satisfied – or, conversely, very dissatisfied – are more likely to respond. Bear this in mind when interpreting the results.
  • A signal is not a cause. A complaint about slow communication may indicate a potential bottleneck. Check within your process whether that stage is actually slow, or whether the initial expectation was simply unrealistic.

At FosFor, analysing the recruitment process and improving touchpoints forms part of Candidate Journey Optimisation, with the aim of reducing drop-out rates. Read more in our data-driven approach how campaigns, shortlisting and follow-up come together.

Have you noticed that candidates are dropping out and aren’t quite sure why? Start by asking your last ten applicants three short questions. Would you like to discuss what the answers mean for your vacancy afterwards? Discuss your situation with us.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.