Do you want to target your job vacancies for mechanics, operators or shipbuilders on Facebook, Instagram or LinkedIn? Then it’s not just about who you reach, but also about what data you use to do so. The short answer: using general audience characteristics and truly anonymous insights to guide your campaign is different from processing or uploading personal data yourself. As soon as information can be traced back to an individual – even through a combination of data or after pseudonymisation – you fall under the GDPR. Using data from your own staff to create a lookalike audience requires extra caution.
This article provides a practical framework for the GDPR and targeted advertising in recruitment. It does not constitute legal advice. For a comprehensive assessment of your campaign, you will need a privacy specialist; we will come back to this later.
Target audience segmentation or personal data: where is the line drawn?
When segmenting your target audience, you determine what type of candidate you want to reach. This could be a region, a field of expertise or a job level. You are describing a group, not an individual.
The processing of personal data involves information relating to an identifiable individual. The European Commission defines personal data as all information relating to an identified or identifiable living individual. Even separate pieces of information that, when taken together, point to a single person, count towards the total.
Two points from that same explanation are directly relevant to recruitment campaigns:
- Pseudonymised or encrypted data is not anonymous. Data that can still be linked to an individual remains personal data and is subject to the GDPR.
- True anonymity is out of the question. Only when a person can no longer be identified, and that anonymisation is irreversible, does the data cease to be personal data.
Keep an eye out for small groups. In a niche field such as marine electrical engineering, a combination of place of residence, age and specialism may point to just one person. In practice, a ‘segment’ may therefore be an individual.
What does the advertising platform do, and what do you do?
When you select targeting criteria on an advertising platform, the platform processes its users’ data. That does not mean that you, as an advertiser, are not involved. The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has drawn up guidelines on targeting on social media. According to the Data Protection Authority focusing on the roles and responsibilities of both advertisers and social media providers, as well as the privacy risks for users and the legal basis for data processing. A draft version was published in October 2020; the final text has been amended following feedback.
What data is involved in a recruitment campaign?
Not all data in a campaign carries the same weight. It helps to consider, for each type of data, whether it relates to a group or to identifiable individuals.
| Data type | Does this involve personal data? | What should you look out for? |
|---|---|---|
| Public labour market data and aggregated figures | Not if no one can be identified | In the case of small groups, check whether a combination of characteristics still points to a single person |
| Insights into the target audience from research, such as what operators consider important | Not if the results are irreversibly anonymous | Pseudonymised responses accompanied by a key remain personal data |
| Targeting criteria in an advertising platform | The platform processes its users’ data | As an advertiser, you also have a role to play; find out which responsibilities apply to you |
| Lists containing details of (former) employees or previous job applicants | Yes, even if they are encrypted or pseudonymised | Check the original purposes; in the case of a new purpose, compatibility, legal basis and any necessary consent require a separate assessment |
You can find out how to pinpoint exactly who you’re looking for without using personal data in the article on carry out a target audience analysis for blue-collar vacancies. When selecting a region and role for your targeting, Job vacancy targeting by region and role a good starting point.
Lookalike audiences based on your own staff: the risks
The idea sounds logical: your best technicians fit the profile you’re looking for, so why not let a platform find similar people? However, as soon as you use employee data for this purpose, you are processing personal data. You should therefore first check whether this use is consistent with the purposes for which you collected that data.
Risk 1: a new purpose for existing data
First, check the purposes for which you originally collected and recorded your staff data. If advertising targeting is not one of them, then a lookalike audience constitutes a new purpose. According to the European Commission, data collected on the basis of, for example, a legitimate interest or a contract may, in certain situations, be used for a different purpose. However, only after you have checked that the new objective is compatible with the original objective. To do this, you should look at the following, amongst other things:
- the link between the original and the new objective;
- the context in which you collected the data, such as the relationship between you and the employee;
- the type of data and whether it is sensitive;
- the potential consequences for the individual;
- appropriate safeguards, such as encryption or pseudonymisation.
Risk 2: Obtaining staff consent is difficult
You might be thinking: I’ll just ask my staff for their consent. According to the European Commission, consent must be freely given. People must be able to refuse or withdraw their consent without suffering any detriment. Where there is a clear imbalance, such as between an employer and an employee, consent is not freely given. So having a member of staff tick a box is not necessarily the answer.
Risk 3: Encryption does not make data anonymous
A hashed or encrypted list feels secure. However, as long as data can be traced back to an individual, it remains personal data under the GDPR. Encryption may, however, be taken into account as a safeguard in the compatibility assessment.
Would you still like to consider a lookalike approach? If so, set out in advance the purpose, the data and the legal basis you will be using, and have these assessed before any list is sent to a platform.
Where can you find a legally sound answer?
This article sets out the guidelines. Whether your specific campaign meets the requirements depends on your approach, your platform and your data. For further information, please contact:
- Your data protection officer or privacy officer, if your organisation has one.
- A privacy lawyer or adviser who can assess your advertising strategy and data flows.
- The Dutch Data Protection Authority, which publishes explanations and refers to the EDPB guidelines on targeting on social media.
When attending such a meeting, be sure to specify exactly which targeting criteria you wish to use, whether you will be uploading lists yourself, and what happens on your job vacancy page – for example, with a form or a tracking pixel.
How does this relate to the retention period for job application data?
This article deals with the phase before and during the advertising process. As soon as a candidate applies, a new situation arises: you receive CVs, cover letters and, later on, notes and scorecards. Separate agreements apply regarding the purpose and retention period for these documents.
We’ll deal with that stage separately. Read how long you are allowed to keep job application details under the GDPR and, if you use appraisal forms, the retention period for scorecards and interview notes.
One point is important, however: data from previous job applicants has been collected in the context of a job application. If you wish to use it later to target an advertising audience, this may constitute a new purpose. In that case, you should first check the purposes for which you collected the data and whether using it for advertising is compatible with those purposes.
Checklist for your next recruitment campaign
- Describe your target audience in terms of group characteristics: region, field of expertise, level of experience.
- Check whether your insights are truly anonymous, even within small niche groups.
- Do not upload lists containing the personal data of employees or former job applicants without first assessing the purpose and legal basis.
- Do not assume that encryption or pseudonymisation renders the GDPR inapplicable.
- Make a note of which data you are using and why, so that you can explain it.
- Have any cases of doubt assessed by a privacy specialist.
Targeted campaigns and privacy go hand in hand if you start by asking what matters to your target audience, rather than which personal data you can use. FosFor uses target audience data and public labour market data to drive its campaigns. Curious to see how this works in practice? Take a look at our data-driven approach or discuss your vacancy with us. Your privacy specialist remains the point of contact for any legal assessment of your campaign.