blue-collar job interview by telephone, video or in person

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

You’ve finally received a reply from a mechanic, operator or welder. You don’t want to waste days trying to arrange an interview that doesn’t fit into their schedule. So the question isn’t just what you discuss, but also how: should the interview be by phone, via video, or in person straight away?

The short answer: there is no single format that always works best. Of the three formats, a telephone interview places the least demand on the candidate: no travel time, no laptop and no link. Video works well if someone can simply join in using their mobile phone. A face-to-face interview is preferable as soon as the workplace, the specialist skills required or the team play a role in the decision. In practice, you combine them in successive stages.

This article is about choosing the right method. You can read about which questions to ask and how to score in How to conduct a structured interview in 8 steps.

Why the format of the interview matters for blue-collar roles

Does your target audience work shifts, on a building site, at a shipyard or whilst travelling to clients? If so, sitting at a desk at a fixed time during office hours isn’t necessarily a given. A candidate who is currently on the night shift has other things on their mind at ten o’clock in the morning.

Every additional requirement in your process is a point at which someone might decide it isn’t worth the effort. Think of things like asking for time off, installing an app, travelling time or borrowing a laptop. The format of the interview determines how many of these requirements you impose, even before the interview itself begins.

That is why it pays to take it step by step: what do you need to know at this stage, and which format places the least demand on the candidate?

Initial contact by telephone: which barrier is removed?

A phone call requires almost nothing: no camera, no link, no travel time. A candidate can call after their shift or during their break, wherever they happen to be at the time.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

This is in line with how people in the Netherlands use the internet. According to the CBS In 2025, 96 per cent of people aged 12 and over used a mobile phone or smartphone for online activities, compared with 73 per cent who used a laptop. These figures apply to the population as a whole, not specifically to blue-collar candidates. They do, however, show that the mobile phone is the device most people use to go online.

An initial telephone conversation is ideal for a brief pre-screening. You check the essential requirements, such as availability, shift work, a driving licence or any compulsory certificates, and explain what the next step is. You can find out how to keep this brief and honest in setting up a short pre-screen without losing talent.

The limitation is clear: you can’t see the person, and you can’t see their craftsmanship. So use the phone call to decide whether to continue the conversation, not to assess someone’s practical skills.

Practical tips for the phone call:

  • Let the candidate choose from a few time slots, including outside office hours if your team can accommodate this.
  • Please send a brief message in advance stating the time, who will be calling and how long the call will last.
  • Call at the agreed time. If you can’t get hold of each other, arrange a new time straight away.

You can read more about cancelled appointments in Preventing technical candidates from failing to turn up for a job interview.

When is a video call practical enough?

Video adds a visual element. You can see each other, a manager at another location can join in, and you can show something. For this target group, video is particularly practical if the candidate can simply take part using their mobile phone, without a laptop.

An example from abroad: the Sheffield City Council (United Kingdom) allows candidates to take part in video interviews via Microsoft Teams using a Windows or Apple computer, or their mobile phone. According to them, anyone joining via a mobile phone should ensure they have a strong connection; 4G is fine provided the signal is good. They recommend practising with someone beforehand to test the camera, microphone and connection.

That is how one employer operates, but the points to consider can be used as a checklist for your own process:

  • Device: Can the candidate take part using just a mobile phone?
  • App or link: Does he need to install anything or create an account? The less, the better.
  • Location: Does he have a quiet place where he can talk after his shift?
  • Connection: What do you do if the picture or sound cuts out? Agree that you’ll just give them a call.
  • Purpose: Does the image offer something that a phone call doesn’t?

If a candidate says they find video calls difficult, don’t turn it into a digital skills test, unless such skills are required for the role. Offer a telephone interview or a face-to-face meeting as an alternative. The rest of your recruitment process should also be conducted over the phone; see Making the recruitment process mobile-friendly for blue-collar workers.

When should you opt for a face-to-face meeting in the workplace?

A face-to-face interview places the greatest demands on the candidate: travel time and finding a slot in their current schedule. However, there are situations where a phone or video call isn’t enough, because you want to show something or see something that isn’t visible on a screen.

  • You want to see craftsmanship in action. A short practical task or a tour of a machine says more than a description ever could.
  • The working environment is a factor in the decision. Think of noise, working at height, a construction site or a production hall with shift work. Make that clear, so the candidate knows what they’re signing up for.
  • The candidate would like to see the team and the workplace for themselves. Just ask; you don’t have to guess.
  • It is the final step before making an offer. A visit gives both parties the chance to see the workplace and the team for themselves before making a decision.

Make the visit as straightforward as possible. Plan it around the candidate’s schedule, let them know who will be meeting them, how long it will take and what they need to bring or wear. Keep it concise: a single in-person appointment that combines a tour of the workplace, meeting the team and the interview takes less time than two separate visits.

Telephone, video and live side by side

Discussion format What is expected of the candidate? What does it go with? Where is the problem?
By telephone A phone and a few minutes at a time of your choosing Initial contact, checking the key terms, answering questions, explaining the next steps You don’t see the person, the workplace or the craftsmanship
Video A phone or computer with a camera, a good internet connection and, sometimes, an app Introduction to video conferencing, remote meeting with a manager It’s tricky without a quiet spot or a good signal; the technology can play up
Live Journey time and time outside the current timetable Showcasing the workplace and team, practical assignment, final step before a job offer It might be too big a step for a first contact

How do you combine different types of conversation in successive steps?

Does your process involve more than one point of contact? If so, choose the format for each step that best suits what you need to know at that stage. A possible structure:

  1. Initial contact by telephone shortly after the application. Check the strict conditions, answer any questions and explain what happens next.
  2. Video as an optional intermediate step. For example, if the manager isn’t on site or if you want a second opinion before someone travels. If it doesn’t provide any new information, just skip it.
  3. Live conversation in the workplace. Combine an introductory meeting, a guided tour and a substantive discussion in a single appointment.
  4. Prompt feedback. After the live interview, ring the candidate to let them know the outcome or what happens next, so they aren’t left waiting.

At each step, ask yourself one question: what do you know now that you didn’t know before? If the answer is ‘nothing’, then that step is really just an extra hurdle.

Do you want to know if your current recruitment process is working? Look at your own figures to see where candidates drop out: between the application and the first phone call, or between the phone call and the face-to-face interview. Treat such a moment as a signal to investigate, not as proof of the cause. Timing, follow-up or your job offer may also play a part. You can read about how to investigate this in Candidate journey analysis: where do candidates really drop out?

Having your own process reviewed

As part of Candidate Journey Optimisation, FosFor analyses the application process and touchpoints, with the aim of engaging candidates more quickly and reducing drop-out rates. FosFor also handles pre-selection and guidance. As a result, clients typically interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. You can see how this works in our data-driven approach.

Are you unsure which interview formats are best suited to your vacancy and target audience? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll go through the steps in your process together.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.