Calculating ROI for recruitment marketing: weighing up costs and quality

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

If you want to calculate the ROI of recruitment marketing, you compare the return on a successful hire against everything you’ve invested in the recruitment process. That return is more than just the number of vacancies filled. You also need to consider what the vacant position cost you, how well the new employee is performing and how long they’ll stay. If a low-cost recruit leaves after a few months, you’ll have to start the recruitment and induction process all over again. That needs to be factored into your calculations too.

In this article, you’ll learn how to combine cost and quality data to form a single overview of performance. We’ve deliberately left out the structure of the campaign budget and the measurement of individual campaign figures. You can read more about that in how the budget for a recruitment campaign is structured and What campaign figures tell you.

Why is looking solely at cost-per-hire an incomplete approach?

Cost-per-hire tells you how much a recruitment cost, not what that recruitment brings in. It’s a useful starting point, but it says nothing about the quality of the person you’ve recruited.

The American HR organisation SHRM also makes that distinction. In a article on measuring the quality of hire One expert interviewed argues that time-to-fill and cost-per-hire are all about the speed and cost of the recruitment process. According to him, they do not show the impact a new hire has on achieving the company’s objectives. He describes them as relevant baseline figures, but not the figures that demonstrate the impact of recruitment.

The same article cites staff turnover, performance, engagement and cultural fit as commonly used indicators of the quality of a recruitment decision. It also includes a caveat: staff turnover, performance appraisals and manager satisfaction are useful indicators, provided you are aware of their limitations. On their own, they do not constitute a comprehensive measure of quality.

For you, this means: use cost-per-hire as one side of the equation. If you want to know which costs you often overlook, read Calculating cost per hire: which costs are you overlooking?

Apart from costs, what other factors contribute to the return on recruitment?

The returns on recruitment consist of several layers. Some can be expressed in euros, whilst others are mainly signals that you track over time. Together, they provide a more accurate picture than a single figure.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

1. Costs avoided by filling a vacant post

As long as a post remains vacant, you’ll miss out on production or turnover and will often have to pay for overtime or temporary staff. The sooner you fill the post, the lower those costs will be. You can find out how to work out those weekly costs yourself in Calculate the weekly cost of a vacant post.

2. Quality of recruitment

How is the new employee performing after a few months? Are they performing to the standard you agreed during the initial interview? Record this using the same criteria you used during the selection process, so that you’re comparing like with like.

3. Retention

An employee who stays on can contribute to your organisation for longer. If they leave soon, this may result in new recruitment and induction costs, on top of what you have already invested in the initial recruitment process.

4. Time spent with your own team

Every interview with an unsuitable candidate costs a manager or recruiter hours of their time. Fewer, but better, interviews also yield results, even if it’s harder to quantify those in monetary terms.

5. Structural intake

Do you regularly look for the same types of roles, such as mechanics or operators? If so, a recruitment campaign that also provides candidates for future vacancies offers greater value than a one-off recruitment drive. Read more about this in the maths behind sustainable recruitment.

How do you balance the speed of completion against the quality of the recruitment process?

Speed and quality are not opposites, but they do need to be assessed together. Filling a vacancy quickly scores highly in terms of the costs avoided by leaving the post vacant. If the candidate leaves shortly afterwards, however, some of that saving may be lost and you will incur recruitment and induction costs once again.

A handy way to weigh this up is to use a simple matrix:

Situation What this means for your earnings What to look out for
Quick to fill in, good match Low costs associated with outstanding payments and an employee who makes a contribution What made this approach successful? Repeat that.
Quick to fill in, poor match Short-term gains, risk of rapid failure Was the shortlist rigorous enough?
Took a while to complete, good match High costs of outstanding payments, but a sustainable assumption What caused the delay in the proceedings?
Slow to fill in, poor match High costs associated with staff turnover, plus the risk of rapid staff attrition leading to further recruitment and induction costs Take another look at the offering, channels and process

Here’s a tip: decide in advance what the minimum quality standard for a project should be. Only then should you focus on speed. That way, you’ll avoid confusing haste with efficiency.

How do you link retention to a campaign’s return on investment?

You link retention to a campaign by tracking which channel or campaign each employee came through. Only then can you see later which source brings in people who stay and perform well.

SHRM describes this principle in a article on talent analytics. According to that article, analysis can reveal which channels yield candidates who are not only hired, but also perform well and stay with the company for longer. By comparing scores from assessments and interviews with subsequent job performance, HR can assess which selection methods have genuine predictive value.

In practice, this is how you go about it:

  1. Record the source. For each applicant, make a note of the channel or campaign through which they applied.
  2. Keep a record of the selection scores. Use a standard scorecard so that you can compare results later.
  3. Choose fixed measurement times. For example, after the probationary period and after a year. At that point, check whether the employee is still with the company and how they are performing.
  4. Compare by source. For each campaign or channel, compare the costs with the number of staff who have remained and are performing well.
  5. Adjust the steering. Invest more in sources that yield sustainable hires, even if their cost per hire is higher.

Do bear in mind the limitations, however. With small sample sizes, a difference between two channels is not particularly meaningful, and staff turnover may also have other causes, such as the line manager or the rota. You should therefore view the results as an indication to investigate further, not as definitive proof. You can read about how to compare selection scores with subsequent job performance in Compare interview scores with performance after 90 days.

How to bring everything together in a single yield overview

A useful performance overview doesn’t have to be complicated. For each campaign, simply place four blocks side by side:

  • Investment: media budget, agency fees and your own team’s hours.
  • Avoided costs: the number of weeks you completed more quickly than with your previous approach, multiplied by your weekly costs for outstanding balances.
  • Quality: the proportion of new recruits who meet the agreed criteria after the probationary period.
  • Retention: the proportion of new recruits who are still in service after one year.

Investment and avoided costs are the inputs for an ROI estimate. The calculation is: (estimated financial return − investment) ÷ investment × 100%. For the estimated return, use the costs avoided compared with your previous approach. Establish this basis for comparison, as without a fixed basis the result cannot be compared. In words: subtract the investment from the estimated financial return, divide that difference by the investment and multiply the result by 100%. To do this, enter your own investment and your own estimated avoided costs. Quality and retention are not factored into this figure. You use them separately to check how sustainable the result is: if a recruit leaves shortly after starting, you’ll have to start the recruitment and induction process all over again. A campaign with a good ROI on paper but low retention warrants a critical review of the pre-selection process and the expectations set out in the job advertisement.

At FosFor, we work according to this principle: not just filling a vacancy, but focusing on a sustainable flow of high-quality candidates. Vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks on average, and clients typically interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month, as we handle the pre-selection and support. In a weekly strategic meeting, we discuss campaigns, results and next steps, and we continuously optimise our approach based on data. You can read more about how this works on the page about our data-driven approach.

Are you still unsure whether to go for it? Then this will help this comparison between recruitment marketing and a temporary employment agency to compare the options side by side.

Do your own maths

Start small: take your last three assumptions and, for each person, identify the source, the turnaround time and the current status. This will give you an initial indication of where you might be losing efficiency – in speed, in matching or in retention. With so few assumptions, this is a starting point for further investigation, not hard evidence.

Would you like to work through the figures with us for a vacancy you’re currently struggling to fill? Discuss your vacancy and we’ll check what data you already have and what you’re still missing.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.