Do you want to attract more women to engineering, manufacturing or other blue-collar roles? Then don’t start with a separate campaign, but by asking what a female candidate actually sees when she looks at your job advert, your visuals and your team. Often, the barrier isn’t the role itself. It lies in language tailored to a single type of candidate, in requirements that sound stricter than necessary, and in doubts about what the workplace is really like.
Below, you can read about where these barriers come from and how to adapt your job advertisement and visuals without giving the impression that you are simply trying to meet a quota.
Why are women still under-represented in technical recruitment?
There is a group of technically trained women who do not work in a technical profession. According to the Statistics Netherlands’ (CBS) 2024 Emancipation Monitor In 2023, 31 per cent of women (aged 15 to 65) with a qualification in engineering, industry or construction were working in a technical occupation. Among men with such a qualification, the figure was 51 per cent. These technical occupations include, amongst others, process operators, construction and industrial technicians, and construction and metalworkers.
Those figures do not explain why the difference exists. They do, however, show that professional expertise is found outside the technical sector. For an employer with a hard-to-fill vacancy, this is a group that should not simply be overlooked.
In practice, this target group is often overlooked because job adverts are written based on the people who are already working there. The job title, the photos and the tone reflect the existing team. That is understandable, but it also means that your recruitment message mainly appeals to people who already recognise themselves in that image.
What barriers are involved in applying for jobs in blue-collar sectors?
A female candidate who is unsure often asks herself a few practical questions: will I fit into this team, will I be taken seriously, and can I balance this job with my life outside work? Your job advertisement answers those questions, whether consciously or unconsciously.
In its white paper ‘Women in Engineering and IT’, the knowledge organisation VHTO outlines four major reasons why women leave the engineering sector:
- gender bias in the workplace, which makes women feel uncomfortable;
- a lack of self-confidence, because women are more often required to prove themselves;
- work-life balance;
- a masculine corporate culture.
VHTO summarises this as a lack of social safety. Please note: this concerns reasons for leaving, not reasons for not applying. Nevertheless, it is useful for your recruitment efforts. If these are the issues causing women in engineering to drop out, it stands to reason that a candidate will take them into account even before applying.
Language also plays a part. A UK Government guidance on inclusive job adverts refers to research showing that words associated with male stereotypes can lead women to believe that the role involves a male-dominated team into which they do not fit. Such language can make a role less attractive and deter women from applying. Although this is a British guideline, the lesson is highly applicable to Dutch job vacancies.
How do you adapt the job advertisement text and image without implying a quota?
The aim is not to create a vacancy ‘for women’. The aim is to create a vacancy with which every suitable candidate can identify. That is also the legal basis: according to the rules on equal treatment at work You must not exclude applicants on the basis of gender, unless this is necessary for the role. The job advert must make it clear that both men and women are eligible, and it must only include requirements that are relevant to the job.
Language and job title
Choose a neutral job title and read through your text critically, checking for words such as ‘tough’, ‘dominant’ or ‘competitive’. The British guideline cites the latter two as examples of terms best avoided. Instead, describe what someone does: troubleshooting faults, setting up a machine, or commissioning a system together with a colleague.
Requirements that are genuinely necessary
A long list of ‘must-haves’ puts off candidates who do not meet every criterion. The UK guidelines recommend shortening such a list and phrasing it more broadly, for example by stating ‘you have experience with some of these skills’. For each requirement, ask yourself: would I really reject someone if this were missing? If not, then it shouldn’t be included among the hard requirements. In our article on Setting knockout criteria without missing out on talent You’ll find out how to make that distinction.
Balancing work and private life in practical terms
Work-life balance is on the VHTO list. So make sure you clearly explain how your rota works: fixed shifts, shift-swapping rules, start times and leave. This helps every candidate, not just women. In the article about terms and conditions of employment that operators consider important There is a table to set out such conditions in concrete terms. Only promise what you can deliver: a ‘flexible timetable’ that isn’t flexible in practice will cost you trust.
Visual material
Show real colleagues and the real workplace. Are there women working in your technical team, and would they like to be featured? If so, a photo of them at work says more than any sentence about diversity. If there aren’t any women working there yet, don’t use stock photos that suggest a team doesn’t exist. Candidates will realise this on their first visit, and by then you’ll have already lost their trust. In that case, choose images of the work, the equipment and the workplace itself.
Things you’d be better off not doing
- No job advert that suggests you are looking for ‘a woman specifically’.
- No questions about family or plans to have children during the interview; according to the central government, this is not permitted during a job interview.
- Not a separate campaign that portrays the work itself as something other than what it is.
What role does your current team play?
Your team is the face of the organisation to this target group. A well-written job advertisement is of no use if, during the tour, a candidate realises that people are making jokes at her expense or that nobody is answering her questions. VHTO identifies social safety as a key factor: can you be yourself, ask questions and set your boundaries without fear of the consequences?
So, before you start recruiting externally, have a look within your organisation first:
- How do managers deal with questions, mistakes and limitations on the part of new colleagues? VHTO notes that many managers in the engineering sector have progressed from technical roles, where little attention was paid to soft skills.
- Are the necessary facilities in place, such as changing rooms, suitable workwear and PPE?
- Who conducts the interview and the tour? A structured interview helps to assess every candidate against the same criteria. Find out how to reduces bias in job interviews.
- Are current staff members – both men and women – willing to explain why they’re staying? That will provide credible arguments for your EVP for technical and blue-collar roles.
Test your message rather than taking a guess
You won’t know what appeals to female candidates in your region and for your role until you measure it. Compare two versions of your job advert side by side – for example, one using neutral language and simplified requirements, and your current text. Don’t just look at the number of applications, but also at who is applying and how many candidates are suitable. You can read about how to do this reliably in A/B testing of job advertisement copy.
Employers often believe that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that a target audience has different preferences. That is why FosFor provides advice on terms of employment, communication and the recruitment process, based on target audience data and campaign data. Would you like to know how this works in practice? Take a look at our data-driven approach or the results by sector.
Are you unsure whether your job advert, images and application process are appealing to the right candidates? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll work with you to identify the obstacles in your situation.