Do technicians, operators or sales staff regularly leave within the first year? If so, your exit interviews may provide useful insights for your recruitment. Recurring reasons for leaving will give you clues as to which promises in your job advertisement you should scrutinise more closely and which expectations you might be able to describe more honestly.
The short answer: look out for the following in your exit interviews recurring Distinguish between reasons for leaving that relate to the role or organisation and those linked to personal circumstances, and translate these patterns into specific, honest information in your job advertisement and employer brand narrative. A single heated conversation is no reason to change your message. A recurring pattern, however, is a reason to take a closer look at your message and your actual practices.
This idea is not new. In its guidelines for federal government organisations, the US Office of Personnel Management (OPM) describes exit surveys as a good way of identifying trends in reasons for leaving, and states that this information can help to to improve recruitment, selection and retention strategies. That source refers to the US federal government, but the principle is easily applicable: make the collection of reasons for leaving a standard part of the exit process, so that you can identify patterns.
Which reasons for leaving, as identified in exit interviews, are relevant to recruitment?
Not every reason for leaving says anything about your recruitment message. A house move or a partner finding work elsewhere is a personal matter. Reasons for leaving that relate to the job itself, the working conditions or the expectations at the start of employment are, however, useful. The question you should ask for each topic is: Could this employee have known this in advance if we’d been honest about it?
The table below will help you categorise common themes. These are examples to help you organise your own exit data; they do not represent a ranked list of reasons for leaving.
| Topic for the exit interview | What it might say about your recruitment | What you can do in this role |
|---|---|---|
| The rota, overtime or travelling time were disappointing | The job advert may have painted an overly rosy or vague picture of working hours | Specify services, peak periods, work locations and journey times in concrete terms |
| The work was different from what I’d expected | The job description did not reflect day-to-day reality | Describe a typical working day, including the less enjoyable tasks |
| No career progression or training | The promised growth was either not specified or not available | Please only mention career paths and training programmes that actually exist |
| Equipment or safety | The working environment did not match the description | Describe tools, machinery and the workplace as they are |
| Management or team atmosphere | It could be a management or retention issue, not necessarily a recruitment problem | Don’t promise a ’great atmosphere’ if that’s not something people can relate to; let real colleagues have their say |
| Salary or terms and conditions | Your offer may not be in line with the market or expectations | Be clear about what you’re offering, rather than using vague terms |
Please note: an issue such as leadership cannot be resolved simply by improving the wording. That falls outside the scope of recruitment. However, you can ensure that your job advert does not promise something that cannot be delivered in practice.
How can you ensure that a job advertisement doesn’t promise things that actually caused staff to leave?
By honestly highlighting both the positive and the less positive aspects of the role. That may sound counterintuitive in a tight labour market, but a candidate who knows in advance what to expect is better placed to judge for themselves whether the role is a good fit.
OPM describes this approach as a Realistic Job Preview (RJP): a recruitment tool that highlights both the positive and negative aspects of a job, enabling candidates to assess for themselves whether they are a good fit. According to OPM, a Job Profile can be useful in reducing staff turnover, provided it is used as a self-assessment tool for the candidate rather than as a selection tool.
Recurring themes from exit interviews help you determine which less appealing aspects you should examine and highlight in such a realistic job preview. Here’s how to go about it:
- Compare your job vacancy with the top three reasons for leaving. Is there anything in the text that contradicts what those who left said? For example, ‘fixed working hours’, whilst people left because of unexpected overtime.
- Remove or qualify that promise. Replace ‘flexible working hours’ with what actually applies, such as the periods during which overtime occurs.
- Be specific and honest about the drawback. ‘During the peak season, you’ll regularly work on Saturdays’ is clearer than a general promise that might cause problems later on.
- Compare that with the things you do do well. An honest drawback comes across as more credible when set against the specific benefits mentioned by those who choose to stay.
Vague terms are of no help here. Candidates cannot base a decision on them, whereas providing specific information about working hours, duties and the workplace actually shows them what to expect.
How does exit data relate to target audience data?
Exit data and target audience data complement each other, but answer different questions. Target audience data shows what candidates in the market consider important. Exit data can provide clues as to where your organisation may not be meeting those expectations; you can then verify these clues by speaking to those who have stayed on and to managers.
At FosFor, we’ve noticed that employers often believe certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group has different preferences. You can read about how to make the most of this external perspective in Using target audience data for your job advertisement and in What the data really reveals about your appeal as an employer.
Exitdata is your internal control. Here are a few combinations you might come across:
- The target group considers something important, whilst those leaving cite it as a problem. This is the first thing you should focus on. Check that the image is correct and, if necessary, adjust the offer or the practice first, and only then the text.
- The target group considers something important, and those who stay cite it as a reason for doing so. This is a potential point to include in your recruitment message, as it resonates with your own staff.
- Detractors mention something that makes the target group attach less importance to it. Mention it honestly in your description, but don’t make it your main message.
Would you like to know how such insights fit into your broader approach? The article on the difference between recruitment marketing and recruitment strategy shows where message and strategy intersect.
When is the signal strong enough to adjust your EVP?
Your employer value proposition (EVP) is the core promise that explains why someone chooses your organisation. You don’t adjust it on the basis of a single interview. A few follow-up questions will help you determine whether a particular point is significant enough:
- Does this theme recur amongst several people who are leaving? Look at a longer period and several roles or teams, rather than a single outlier.
- Does it relate to a pledge in your EVP? If you promise ‘growth’ but those who left actually missed out on growth, your core promise comes under pressure.
- Does it apply if you leave shortly after starting work? Leaving early may indicate a gap between expectations and reality. Check whether this is the case for you, rather than simply assuming it is.
- Do those who stay on or senior staff confirm this view? Compare exit information with interviews with current staff, so that you don’t just hear the negative side of the story.
- Can you change the way things are done? If not, then you adjust the promise. If so, then you change your approach first and your narrative afterwards.
If you answer ‘yes’ to several of these questions, it’s time to review your EVP. You’ll find a step-by-step guide to doing this in Drawing up job descriptions for technical and blue-collar roles.
A few practical points to bear in mind
- Compilation of answers by theme. Use fixed categories so that you can compare your answers over time.
- Keep it anonymous. Do not use any statements from former employees that can be traced back to them in your recruitment materials.
- Test following a change. See if applicants react differently to the more honest wording, and whether the issue comes up less often in exit interviews later on.
From a reason for leaving to a better recruitment message
Exit interviews are not a recruitment tool in themselves, but they are a source of insights. Recurring themes highlighted by staff who stay or by managers provide clues as to where your narrative and your actual practices may be at odds. You can review these points and, where necessary, describe them more honestly in your job adverts.
Start small: take a look at the reasons people left last year, compare them with your current job advertisement and highlight any promises that don’t quite add up. Would you like to link these insights to your target audience data and your campaigns? Find out how our data-driven approach works or discuss your vacancy with us.