You’ve hired a top-class engineer and you want to know which channel led to that hire. Your system says: Google. But the candidate first saw your job advert on Instagram, then read your careers page, and only then clicked on a search advert. So which channel gets the credit?
The short answer: if you want to determine the source of hire when a candidate has had multiple points of contact, a single automatically assigned source will only show part of the journey. Combine the source recorded by your system with the path you can measure and with what the candidate themselves tells you. Assess this for the people you actually hire, not for every application. For a straightforward recruitment drive involving one or two channels, a simple approach may suffice. If you’re recruiting via multiple channels simultaneously, it makes sense to look a little deeper.
Why ‘the last channel before applying for a job’ paints an incomplete picture
A metric that gives all the credit to a single moment only tells part of the story. Google explains that people often carry out multiple searches and click on several adverts before taking a key action, and that the full attribution usually takes you to the most recently clicked advert. Google itself asks whether it was that very last advert that tipped the balance, and what role the earlier clicks played.
Apply that to recruitment. A candidate who wasn’t actively looking might be sparked into interest by a social media advert. Weeks later, they look up your company name and apply for a job. In a last-click model, the search query gets all the credit, even though the social media advert provided the initial nudge.
Not every system measures the same moment
It becomes even more difficult because different tools use different points in time as their source. Workable, for example, states that the source for a candidate is based on the very first time you visit the job application form. If someone applies via LinkedIn but had previously opened the form via the careers page, Workable will show the careers page as the source.
The same candidate may therefore appear under one channel in your advertising dashboard and under another in your application system. Neither is incorrect; they simply measure different points in time. You should therefore first check which criteria your own systems use before comparing the figures side by side.
How do you identify overlapping channels within the same recruitment round?
You can only see overlaps if you can track a candidate’s journey rather than just a single label. To do this, you need a clear end point, such as a submitted application.
In Google Analytics, the attribution path report shows the sequence of touchpoints that leads to a defined key event. Google emphasises that there without a key event, there is no path to display. If you do not set the job application as a measurable goal, you will not be able to see which channels collectively led to that application.
Three fountains side by side
No single source tells the whole story. Taken together, however, they do provide a more reliable picture:
| Source | What it shows | Restriction |
|---|---|---|
| Source in your recruitment system | One registered source per candidate if your system uses a single source field | It depends on the system’s rules; for example, Workable looks at the first visit to the application form |
| Attribution path in analytics | The sequence of recorded points of contact leading up to the job application | Only visible if the application is set as a key event; offline contact that is not recorded digitally does not appear in the path |
| What the candidate says | Where someone first saw you and what made the difference | Based on memory, so not always accurate |
Here’s how to go about it in practical terms
- Assign each channel its own tracking link (UTM code) so that visits can be identified.
- Set the number of applications submitted as a measurable target in your analytics.
- When you first get in touch, ask two questions: where did you first come across us, and what made you decide to apply?
- Write down those answers in a specific place, under specific headings.
- For each assumption, list the system resource, path and candidate answer side by side.
Have you come across a tip from a colleague or a conversation at a recruitment fair? If such contact is not recorded digitally, it will not appear in the attribution trail. You should therefore also ask about it when speaking to the candidate.
Assess the source based on assumptions that work well, not on the basis of all applications
A recruitment channel that generates a large number of applications does not automatically result in candidates who turn out to be high performers. What really matters is the candidates you hire who turn out to be high performers. You should therefore link the source to each stage of the process: application, interview, offer and recruitment.
That only works with clean, consistent data. Greenhouse emphasises that Accurate and consistent data forms the basis for useful reports and recommends setting up your process at an early stage, so that you can rely on the figures when making decisions. So agree in advance who will record the source, which categories you will use, and what you will do if the system and the candidate give conflicting information.
Would you like to gain a better understanding of the quality of your intake? Then read on to find out how you can measure the quality of your pool of applicants. There is a separate article on campaign performance metrics, such as reach and conversion, Measuring recruitment campaign figures.
What does this mean for allocating your budget?
If you only look at the final channel, you run the risk of ruling out a channel that actually sparked your initial interest. Conversely, a channel that mainly appears as the final step may be given more credit than it deserves.
You should therefore consider the role a channel plays. Does it often open up the pathway, or does it often close it off? A channel that first introduces candidates has a different purpose to one where people return to apply for jobs. This is a matter of judgement, not a fixed formula: the path data and candidate responses provide you with indicators, not proven causes.
Reallocate your budget step by step and keep tracking what happens to the intake of suitable candidates. Find out how to targeting by region and role defines the scope within a channel. If you want to know the total cost of an assumption, take a look at Costs you often overlook when calculating cost per hire.
When is a simple ‘source of hire’ sufficient?
Not every recruitment round requires pathway analysis. A simple source registration is often sufficient when:
- whether you use one or two channels;
- candidates usually apply shortly after the initial contact;
- you have few vacancies at any one time and choosing a channel has little impact on your budget.
A more comprehensive approach is more likely to pay off if:
- you use several channels at the same time to advertise the same vacancy;
- you approach people who aren’t actively looking for work and who take longer to apply;
- you regularly recruit from the same limited pool of candidates and your budget decisions are systematic.
Are you unsure? Start by asking the candidate the question and recording the source. That way, you can see whether your system source differs from what candidates themselves say. If there are frequent discrepancies, that’s a reason to set up the tracking path in analytics as well.
From one-off labels to a regular measurement schedule
Determining the source of hire only becomes valuable if you do it consistently. At FosFor, we combine recruitment, data and marketing, and we continuously optimise campaigns based on data, with a weekly strategic meeting to discuss campaigns, results and next steps. Read more in our data-driven approach how campaigns, shortlisting and follow-up come together.
Would you like to know which channels in your recruitment processes really help you make good hires? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll look at your current results together.