Measuring retention after recruitment: how to assess the quality of your recruitment

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Your vacancy for a mechanic has been filled after a few weeks. On paper, that’s a success. If that same mechanic leaves after four months, you’ll have to start all over again, and that quick fill was really just a stopgap. Measuring retention after recruitment shows whether your recruitment efforts yield lasting results or merely fill gaps temporarily.

The short answer: measure, for each group of new employees (a cohort), how many are still in post at specific points in time. Link that result to the recruitment channel and to the selection stages the candidate went through. Interpret a low figure as a signal to investigate, not as proof that your recruitment is failing. After all, there are reasons for staff leaving that have nothing to do with recruitment.

Why does ‘time-to-hire’ alone say nothing about the sustainability of a recruitment decision?

Time-to-hire measures how quickly a candidate progresses from application to accepting an offer. It does not measure whether that candidate is a good fit or will stay. Filling a vacancy quickly and an early departure can go hand in hand.

The trade association SHRM also warns against placing too much emphasis on speed. According to the experts in their article, this varies greatly depending on the role, and it is better to use ‘time-to-hire’ as a health indicator that highlights friction in the process. The same article states that rushing to fill vacancies can be at the expense of quality.

Speed remains important, particularly when it comes to hard-to-find roles where candidates are quick to accept offers elsewhere. If you want to speed up your process, read on in Improving time to hire through measurement and process optimisation how to go about it. But without a retention strategy to go with it, you won’t know whether you’re attracting the right people more quickly or the wrong ones.

In Which recruitment KPIs are suitable for hard-to-find roles? There are several metrics to consider. This article focuses on one of them: how long people stay once they have started.

Over what time frame does it make sense to measure retention for blue-collar and technical roles?

There is no fixed timeframe that applies to every role. Choose several assessment points so that you can identify both early dropouts and those who leave later on.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

Gallup states that the The ideal duration of the onboarding process may vary depending on the role and sector: from the first 30 or 90 days up to 150 days or even beyond the first year. This relates to induction, not retention. Nevertheless, it’s a useful approach: compare your measurement points with the period during which someone is still settling in.

Our advice is to work with three stages:

  • After approximately 90 days: Here you can see early drop-outs. In production, engineering and logistics, three months is often the point at which it becomes clear whether someone has got the basics of the job under control, such as pace, safety and teamwork.
  • After six months: The first impression is over. Leaving at this stage may indicate that expectations have not been met.
  • After twelve months: Someone has gone through a full cycle, including busy and quiet periods or seasonal work.

Do you work with shift patterns, project-based work or seasonal peaks? If so, choose measurement points that align with those patterns. A temporary contract coming to an end is different from an employee leaving of their own accord. Make sure you record that difference, otherwise it will skew your figures.

Here’s how to work it out

Take all employees who joined during the same period, for example, in a single quarter. Count how many are still employed after 90 days and divide that figure by the number of new recruits. Repeat this after six and twelve months. This allows you to compare cohorts fairly with one another.

Do you only take on a handful of people a year for the same role? In that case, a percentage doesn’t tell you much. A single departure can cause your figure to fluctuate significantly. In that case, look at what happened on a case-by-case basis and gather data over a longer period before drawing any conclusions.

How do you link retention figures back to the recruitment channel or selection process?

Retention only becomes useful once you know where someone came from and which route they took. This means you need to record a few details every time you take on a new employee.

SHRM explains how talent analytics can demonstrate which recruitment channels produce candidates who are not only hired, but also perform well and stay with the company for longer. According to the same source, by tracking assessment scores, interview evaluations and subsequent performance, you can assess which selection methods really add value.

For each assumption, be sure to record at least the following:

Given Why you need it
Recruitment channel To see whether people coming from, for example, social media campaigns, job sites or referrals stay for different lengths of time
Campaign or job advertisement To check whether a particular message raises expectations that are not met
Completing the selection stages To see whether a pre-screen, case study or taster day is linked to students staying on for longer
Scores from an interview or scorecard To check whether your assessment says anything about staying
Start date, team and line manager To be able to examine factors other than recruitment separately
Reason for leaving To distinguish between voluntary departure, dismissal and expiring contracts

If you’d also like to compare performance figures after three months with your interview scores, then this will help Compare interview scores with performance after 90 days. Retention and performance go hand in hand: someone may stay on and perform poorly, or perform well and still leave.

Have you noticed that people from a particular recruitment channel tend to leave early? If so, that’s a reason to look into it more closely. It doesn’t necessarily prove that the channel is the cause. Perhaps those people mainly ended up in one particular team, or in a role that happened to be filled during a difficult period.

When does a low retention rate indicate a recruitment problem?

A low figure tells you that something is going wrong, but not where. That is the biggest pitfall of this KPI.

In an SHRM article on the quality of hire, an expert interviewed states that Retention is more difficult to measure because many factors other than the quality of the candidate determine how long someone stays. His example: an excellent recruit with a poor manager. If that employee is poached, it says nothing about the recruiter who brought them in.

You should therefore use these questions to help you decide which direction to take. They are exploratory questions, not a definitive diagnosis.

Signs pointing towards recruitment

  • Those who leave say that the role, the rota or the terms and conditions were different from what they had expected.
  • Early drop-off is particularly common when a single channel, campaign or job advertisement is shared across different teams.
  • Those who left scored poorly during the selection process on criteria that later proved to be important, or those criteria were not assessed.

Signs pointing towards onboarding or leadership

  • Staff turnover is concentrated within a single team or under a single manager, regardless of the recruitment channel.
  • People cite a lack of guidance, unclear duties or poor induction.
  • Staff turnover tends to occur mainly later on, following a reorganisation, a change to the rota or a change in leadership.

Always ask for feedback when you leave, preferably through a structured exit interview with the same set of questions. A brief, honest explanation is more valuable than a polite, standard phrase. If you’re unsure about your induction period, then What do you include in a 90-day development plan for a new employee? something to hold on to.

How to get started with retention as a recruitment KPI

  1. Choose your cohorts. Group new recruits by quarter or by job category.
  2. Record your measurement times. For example, 90 days, six months and twelve months.
  3. Record the source and selection route for each intake. Reconstructing events after the fact rarely works out well.
  4. Different types of departure. Voluntary resignation, dismissal and expiring contracts should not all be lumped together.
  5. Discuss the figures with HR and managers together. Only then can you distinguish between recruitment and onboarding.
  6. Change only one thing at a time. If you change your job advertisement text, channel and selection criteria all at once, you won’t know what made the difference.

At FosFor, the focus is on ensuring a sustainable flow of high-calibre candidates, not just on filling individual vacancies. In our weekly strategic meetings, we discuss campaigns, results and next steps. Read more in our data-driven approach how campaigns, shortlisting and follow-up come together.

Do you find that people are leaving sooner than you’d like, and do you want to know if it’s down to your recruitment process? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll work out together where best to start.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.