Compete for the same candidates – that’s how you stay ahead of the rest

7-minute read

Tadaah team meeting

Have you noticed that your candidate is also in talks with other employers? If so, there’s little point in simply going through your recruitment process at a leisurely pace and only responding at the very end. Those competing for the same candidates gain the upper hand by doing three things: responding quickly and predictably, setting out in advance who will make the decision and when, and delivering a message that dispels any doubts before they arise. Speed is no substitute for a suitable offer. But a good offer that arrives too late may still lose out.

This article focuses on the tactical side: what to do during an ongoing recruitment process. Would you first like to systematically assess how your job vacancy, salary and terms and conditions compare with those of other employers? If so, read our guide on labour market competition analysis.

How can you tell that you’re competing for the same candidates?

The clearest sign is simple: the candidate tells you themselves. SHRM describes exactly this situation: you are in the middle of the selection process for a key role, a few top candidates are through to the second round of interviews, and one of them mentions that they have received an offer from another company (SHRM). By that point, there’s already a concrete offer on the table, and you have less scope to simply wait and see.

There are also less obvious signs. They do not prove anything, but they are a reason to probe further:

  • The candidate specifically asks how long your procedure takes or when they will receive a decision.
  • Replies to your messages become slower or shorter, or appointments are rescheduled.
  • You’ll see the same role advertised by several employers in the region at the same time.
  • The candidate asks questions that mainly focus on making comparisons: terms and conditions, timetable, start date.

A slow response might simply mean they’re busy or have doubts about the role. So don’t just guess – ask the question outright: “Are you also in talks with other companies, and what’s your timeline?” An honest answer will help you adjust your own plans accordingly.

What role does reaction speed play in the selection process?

Greenhouse notes that top candidates often move quickly: they accept another offer or pull out if they sense that your interest has waned. At the same time, overburdened recruitment teams often end up slowing the process down, as they try to balance urgency with thoroughness (Greenhouse). The pace of your process is therefore something to bear in mind if a candidate has several options.

Would you like to find out more about data-driven recruitment?
Discover how AI, target audience data and labour market insights can help you attract the right candidates. Download our white paper for practical insights, or feel free to get in touch for advice tailored to your organisation.

That last point is all too familiar. An extra chat “just to be on the safe side”, a colleague who needs to have a quick look, feedback that takes a week to come through. Each step seems small. For a candidate who has another offer on the table, that same silence can feel as though your interest has waned.

Find out where the time goes

You can’t improve speed by feel alone. LinkedIn recommends looking at the time taken for each stage of the recruitment process: from the day a candidate enters a stage to the day they reach the next stage. This shows where the process is getting bogged down (LinkedIn).

First, take a look at your own data: is the delay between the application and the initial contact, between the first and second interviews, or between the final interview and the job offer? That’s where your first area for improvement lies. Practical steps:

  • Schedule the follow-up appointment at the end of the conversation, rather than sending an email afterwards.
  • Give a specific date for your feedback and stick to it, even if the answer isn’t final yet.
  • When you have good news, give them a call rather than sending an email. That way, you’ll find out straight away if they have any questions or concerns.

You can read more ideas in our article on Speeding up the recruitment process without compromising on quality.

How can you avoid a slow internal decision-making process?

Delays can also arise within your own organisation. Who needs to give approval? Is the line manager authorised to make an offer themselves? What if the director is on holiday? If you only sort this out once the ideal candidate is already sitting in front of you, you’ll lose days.

You should therefore set out, before the recruitment process begins, how decisions will be made: what the budget is, how the approval process works, who is responsible for the decision, and what the timeline is. You should also discuss why the role exists and when you need to fill it.

Let’s turn that into a few specific agreements:

Appointment A question you answer in advance
Decision-maker Who makes the decision, and who stands in for that person when they are absent?
Range of products Within what range may the decision-maker make an offer themselves, without requiring further approval?
Decisive moment When, after the final interview, do you discuss the candidate and make a decision?
Timeline What timeframe do you tell candidates, and does it match your schedules?

Having a set structure for the decision-making meeting helps to ensure that discussions do not drag on indefinitely. Please see our Debriefing structure for decision-making meetings. Making quick decisions does not mean making hasty ones: you shift the thinking to before the recruitment process begins, so that the final stages of the process can run smoothly.

What do you make clear in advance to dispel any doubts?

A candidate considering several options at the same time does not necessarily focus solely on salaries. You can yourself clear up any uncertainty regarding the process, the role or the next step, so that the candidate knows exactly where they stand.

So make it clear from the very first contact:

  • How the procedure works: how many steps, who he’s talking to and roughly how long it takes. In our article on Explaining the application process in your job advert You can read about how to include this in the job advertisement.
  • What the job actually involves: timetable, workplace, team and type of projects. For a mechanic or operator, this is more specific than general statements about a pleasant working atmosphere.
  • How he’s getting on: when he will find out if he has got through, and when he can expect an offer.

A targeted message focuses on what the target audience itself considers important, not on what you think is important. Employers often believe that certain benefits are decisive, whilst data shows that the target audience has different priorities. During the interview, simply keep asking: what is the most important factor for this candidate when making their choice?

Would you like to find yourself in direct competition less often? If so, you could also consider candidates who aren’t currently actively looking for a job. Read on to find out how you reached latent jobseekers.

The candidate has already received another offer: what now?

Don’t panic, and don’t start bidding blindly either. Follow these steps:

  1. Ask about the timeframe. When should the candidate decide on the other offer?
  2. Ask what matters most to him. Commute, working hours, career progression or salary? Then you’ll know what to discuss.
  3. See if you can speed up without skipping any steps. Could you bring the next call forward, or arrange for the decision-maker to join straight away?
  4. Be honest if it doesn’t work out. A realistic date gives the candidate more certainty than a vague promise.

Sometimes you make a conscious decision not to speed things up, because a task requires thorough testing. That is a legitimate choice. In that case, do make that decision consciously, and communicate it clearly.

How FosFor supports this

FosFor supports organisations from the campaign stage right through to the application and follow-up stages. We handle the pre-selection and guidance, meaning that clients, on average, only interview the 2 to 4 best candidates per month. As part of Candidate Journey Optimisation, we advise on how to engage candidates more quickly and improve touchpoints during the application process. In a weekly strategic meeting, we discuss campaigns, results and next steps.

First, read how to our data-driven approach What does it look like? Is there currently a vacancy where you find yourself competing with other employers for the same candidates? Discuss your vacancy Get in touch with us, and we’ll work with you to identify where time is being spent in your process.

We would like to get in touch
Get in touch
Good people don’t look for job vacancies. Download the white paper and find out how you can reach them anyway.