Are you consistently struggling to fill your technical vacancies in a region experiencing population decline? In that case, simply advertising more heavily within the same radius around your business often does little to help. As the local workforce shrinks, demand changes. It’s no longer about how to reach more people in the immediate vicinity, but about where your target group actually is and what you need to offer to make the extra journey time worthwhile for them. Labour market data helps you determine whether a wider region, a longer commute or relocation is a realistic solution for your role.
What changes when the local pool of candidates shrinks?
In a normal labour shortage, you compete with other employers for the same pool of candidates. With demographic decline, that pool itself is shrinking. This calls for a different approach, because better job adverts or a larger budget will not increase a shrinking pool of candidates.
The extent to which this is a factor varies from region to region. According to the Statistics Netherlands’ regional population forecast for 2022–2050 The forecast predicts a significant population decline in 54 municipalities (15 per cent). These municipalities are mostly located on the periphery of the Netherlands and are expected to experience a more pronounced ageing of their population than the cities. According to the same forecast, the number of municipalities with a declining population will continue to rise after 2035.
For technical roles, there is also a sector-specific issue to consider. The UWV expects the labour market in many technical professions to become even tighter over the next five years. One of the reasons is that a relatively large number of people in the industry are aged 60 or over (14%), and most of them are due to retire in the coming years. At the same time, the intake of new graduates in science and engineering disciplines is lagging behind.
Does your business operate in a municipality experiencing population decline, and are you looking for technicians, operators or engineers? If so, these two factors could reinforce each other. Whether this applies to your vacancy is something you’ll need to assess on a region-by-region and role-by-role basis.
Market contraction or competition: how do you identify the cause?
An empty inbox doesn’t necessarily explain why it’s empty. It could be down to a decline in the labour market, but it could also be because competitors are offering better terms, a vacancy that nobody is seeing, or a recruitment process where candidates are dropping out. So, look at the data first before drawing any conclusions about the region.
Public sources provide an initial picture. UWV: A Regional Overview provides an insight into job trends, vacancies, labour supply, labour market tightness and trends such as an ageing population, broken down by labour market region. Compare these figures with your own recruitment data. To find out which free sources you can use for this, read our article on labour market data without expensive tools.
The following signs will help you tell the difference. They are indications that warrant further investigation, not proof in themselves.
| What you see | May indicate | What you’re checking |
|---|---|---|
| Competitors in your region are recruiting people with the same profile but on better terms | Competition for the available candidates | Salary, terms and conditions, and visibility of those employers |
| Few similar vacancies and few opportunities in your region | A small or shrinking local pool | Labour supply and an ageing population in the labour market region |
| Good reach and click-through rates, but few completed applications | A hurdle in a vacancy or process | Where candidates drop out: the advert, the application form or the initial contact |
| Applicants mainly come from far away | Local supply is limited, but there is interest further afield | Applicants’ places of residence and where they drop out |
Are you unsure whether competitors are to blame? A labour market competition analysis shows who else is targeting the same profile and what they’re offering.
When is a wider regional search radius required?
A wider search radius makes sense if the local pool for your role is too small and a larger area does contain candidates. That sounds logical, but bigger isn’t automatically better. Every additional kilometre makes the journey longer for the candidate.
So ask yourself these questions:
- Where are the offers? See which neighbouring labour market regions have more people with your profile, for example due to the proximity of similar industries or educational programmes.
- What will the journey be like? A distance on a map doesn’t mean much. Journey time by car or public transport, traffic jams and your shift times determine how tiring the journey feels.
- Who’s already fishing there? In a larger area, you’ll also come across new competitors who are located closer to those candidates.
- Is moving house a realistic option? For some roles, it may be appropriate to ask candidates from further afield to relocate. This is a bigger step for the candidate. During interviews, check whether this is an issue, rather than simply assuming it is.
If you’re expanding your territory, don’t just target a large area with your campaigns. With targeting by region and role Tailor your reach to the locations where your target audience is realistically likely to come from.
What role does willingness to travel play in your recruitment message?
Journey time is a real consideration for candidates. From a survey by the UWV amongst jobseekers It appears that a long commute, alongside low pay, a poor working atmosphere and a poor work-life balance, is a reason for not accepting a job. For most people, a fair wage is the top priority.
What does that mean for your job vacancy? Don’t gloss over the distance. A candidate who only finds out how long the journey is during the interview is likely to drop out at that stage. Instead, be specific about the travel arrangements:
- State the location clearly and describe how easy it is to get there.
- Explain what arrangements you make for travel, such as a travel allowance or any other arrangements you actually offer.
- Show what the candidate gets in return for that travel time, for example in terms of work, the team or career progression.
- Be honest about working hours, so that the candidate can work out how long their journey will take.
You don’t know candidates who live far away as well. So test your message: does an opening line about accessibility work differently in a more remote region than your standard text? Your data will show which version generates more serious applications.
How do you adjust terms and conditions of employment to compensate for longer journeys?
If you’re asking people to travel further, your offer needs to be worth the effort. What makes an offer worthwhile varies depending on the target group. Employers often think that certain benefits are important, whilst data shows that the target group has different priorities. So don’t start with what you find attractive, but with what matters most to your candidates.
Options you could look into:
- Travel expenses. See how your remuneration compares with that of employers located closer to the candidate.
- Timetables and working hours. Fixed timetables or shifts that start outside peak hours can make a long journey more manageable. Check whether this is feasible within your organisation.
- Wages. As pay is the most important factor for most jobseekers, it deserves to be taken into account. Compare the full picture, not just the gross amount.
- Work-life balance. Travel time takes up free time. See how much leeway you can allow to make up for that.
Don’t change everything at once. Adjust just one condition, communicate it clearly, and monitor whether the number of visitors from more distant areas changes.
From data to an approach tailored to your region
Recruiting in a region experiencing population decline is not a one-off exercise. Population trends continue over many years, so a structural approach is more effective than constantly starting from scratch with individual vacancies. Start with three steps: map out the labour supply in your region and the surrounding areas, analyse where your current applicants come from and at which stage they drop out, and determine what conditions would compensate your target group for their commute.
FosFor combines recruitment, data and marketing. Among other things, we carry out labour market and competitive analyses and provide advice on terms of employment and employer positioning based on target audience data. Find out how all this comes together in our data-driven approach, or discuss your vacancy and join us in exploring where your candidates are realistically likely to come from.