Has your vacancy been open for weeks, but nobody in your organisation has the time to really get to grips with it? If so, you can hire in recruitment support. An external provider will then temporarily handle a large part of your recruitment process, from strategy and campaign planning to shortlisting and follow-up. You retain control over who is hired. This […]
This is different from simply placing an advert or just having CVs screened. You bring in recruitment expertise for the entire process, without having to hire your own recruiter straight away. Below, you can read about when this makes sense, what tasks you outsource and what you always keep in-house.
When is it smarter to hire external staff than to take on an in-house recruiter?
Having your own recruiter is a long-term investment. This suits an organisation that has plenty of vacancies throughout the year and wants to build up expertise in-house. Are your recruitment needs more sporadic, or do you mainly struggle to find a few hard-to-find profiles? In that case, temporary support is often the more logical choice.
A useful distinction emerges from the world of recruitment process outsourcing (RPO). According to SHRM In addition to full outsourcing and project-based recruitment, there is also a hybrid model: the organisation retains its own recruitment team but engages an external provider for roles that are difficult to fill or to cope with temporary peaks in demand. The RPO Association describes on-demand recruitment as a way of meeting unpredictable recruitment needs without making permanent changes to your organisation.
Applied to the day-to-day operations of an employer in the engineering, manufacturing, logistics, sales or maritime sectors: hiring temporary staff is often a suitable solution in these situations.
- You do have vacancies, but nobody has the time. HR or the line manager is also involved in recruitment, and this is evident from the response time.
- Job vacancies are few and far between and remain unfilled. Think of technicians, operators, welders or account managers, for whom simply posting a job vacancy yields little result.
- Your question keeps changing. This quarter you’ll be looking for five people; next quarter, perhaps none at all. A permanent recruiter would then be partly out of work.
- You want to find out what works first. Before you set up your own recruitment role, you’ll want to know what message and approach will appeal to your target audience.
Are you unsure? Then ask yourself one question: is this a temporary capacity issue or a long-term need for an in-house recruitment role? The former argues in favour of hiring in, the latter in favour of taking someone on. Many organisations also combine the two: an in-house HR staff member for day-to-day matters and external support for the more challenging roles.
Which parts of the recruitment process do you take care of?
With a broader recruitment capacity, the external provider takes on the role of an in-house recruitment function, either for some of your vacancies or for all of them. The RPO Association describes an RPO provider in exactly this way, covering the entire process – from job profile to onboarding – including people, technology, methodology and reporting. You decide for yourself how far you want to take this.
At FosFor, support extends from the campaign stage through to the application process and follow-up. In practice, this involves the following elements:
- Data-driven strategy. We analyse labour market data, target audience data and competitor data. This allows you to see what candidates in your target audience really value, from terms of employment to communication and the application process. Employers often think that certain benefits are decisive, whilst the data shows that the target audience has different priorities.
- Targeted recruitment campaigns. Data-driven campaigns, social recruitment and online advertising, optimised based on performance.
- Pre-selection and support. We carry out the initial screening and support candidates. On average, clients interview only the 2 to 4 best candidates per month.
- Follow-up and the candidate journey. Prompt communication, clear points of contact and advice to minimise drop-outs during the process.
- Weekly strategic meetings. Every week, we discuss campaigns, results and next steps.
On average, vacancies are filled within 3 to 8 weeks. This is an average, not a guarantee: the role, the target group and your own pace throughout the process all play a part in determining how long it takes. You can read more about the steps in our data-driven approach.
Would you also like to save time on the steps that are handled internally? In the article about AI in recruitment for SMEs read it where it’s realistic to do so.
What remains the client’s responsibility at all times?
Hiring in capacity does not mean you relinquish control of the recruitment process. An external provider can take on a lot of the work, but certain decisions and tasks remain your responsibility. The Australian government agency APSC advises organisations to be clear in advance about which services are required and when – such as recruitment, shortlisting and reference checks – and to clearly set out who is responsible for what.
That lesson applies here too. This is for you to remember:
- The job description and the context. You’ll know exactly what someone will be doing and which team they’ll be in. A good initial interview with specific job requirements is the starting point.
- Decisions regarding terms and conditions of employment. We provide advice based on target audience data, but it’s up to you to decide whether to adjust your salary, working hours or fringe benefits.
- Interviews with the best candidates. You’ll speak to the shortlisted candidates yourself and assess how well they’d fit with your organisation.
- The adoption order. It’s always up to you who you take on.
- Prompt feedback. Good candidates won’t wait around. If you leave feedback unanswered, you’ll lose them, no matter how well the campaign is going.
- The induction. You’ll be organising your new colleague’s first few weeks yourself.
The weekly meeting is the time to ensure these agreements remain on track. You can read about how to organise such a meeting effectively in the article on a Agenda for the weekly recruitment meeting.
How does this compare to outsourcing the pre-selection process alone?
With pre-selection alone, you outsource one step: candidates are already coming in, but you don’t have time to screen them. Broader capacity goes a step further. It is designed for situations where the influx itself is the problem.
| Question | Pre-selection only | Advertisements only | Greater recruitment capacity |
|---|---|---|---|
| What’s your problem? | Too many responses, not enough time to screen them | Insufficient reach amongst the target audience | Not enough time and not enough suitable new students |
| Who is responsible for finding candidates? | You | The external party – you take care of the rest | The external party, from campaign to follow-up |
| Who carries out the screening? | The external party | You | The external party |
| Strategy and target audience insight? | Usually not | Limited to the campaign | Part of the approach |
| What are you up to? | Recruitment, interviews, decision | Screening, follow-up, consultations, decision | Input, interviews with the best candidates, decision |
Are you getting enough responses, but simply don’t have the time to screen them? In that case, with a good short pre-screen make some headway. If the intake falls short, additional screening capacity will be of little help and expanding overall capacity is the more obvious solution.
How to prepare for outsourcing recruitment services
The better your preparation, the quicker the external party can get up and running. These steps will help:
- Identify the problem. Is it down to time, scope, a breakdown in the process, or all three?
- Select the vacancies. Start with the profiles that have been open the longest or cost the most.
- Set out the allocation of roles. Who carries out the initial screening, who conducts the interviews, who makes the decision, and within how many days?
- Set aside some time for feedback. Schedule fixed times to discuss candidates and attend the meetings.
- Agree on how you will measure success. It is not the number of applications, but the quality and sustainability of the intake.
Would you like to know how data-driven recruitment agency FosFor How would you go about filling this hard-to-fill vacancy? Arrange an introductory meeting and discuss where your recruitment process is currently running into difficulties. Then we’ll work out together which parts you’d be best advised to outsource.